From International Regulation to Local Implementation
Gender Equality for Sustainable Development Goals
Abstract
This paper discusses gender equality in sustainable development goals as a response to the 2023 United Nations Sustainable Development Goals Report. Through the lens of international environmental law, gender equality achievement is examined both by its international commitment and its implementation at local institutions. This study focuses on elements of the data report that closely relate to human rights and the environment. These include women’s global share in national agricultural ownership, their secure tenure rights over agricultural land, and access to fair legal protection. This study then observes the availability of international agendas within international environmental law to promote sustainable development goals. Relevant legal frameworks include those arranged by the 1992 Rio Earth Summit and the 2015 Paris Agreement on Climate Change. To examine local implementation, this study uses the West Sumatra government as a case study, employing questionnaires and interviews with provincial legal actors. Indonesia Investment Law, which covers a broad spectrum of human development, is utilized as a model for assessing the implementation of gender equality at the local level. Ultimately, this study found a lack of gender equality implementation for SDGs at local institutions. It concludes that this could have been anticipated via a more comprehensive international legal framework, which could be implemented through national regulations.
Keywords: Environmental Law, Gender Equity, Sustainable Development Goals
References
Adekunle, Hanafi, “Legal Protection on Women’s Property Rights as Panacea to Poverty Reduction and Environmental Sustainability in Uganda” (2022) 4:1 GLS Law J 5–21.
Aftab, Wafa et al, “Implementation of Health and Health-Related Sustainable Development Goals: Progress, Challenges and Opportunities-a Systematic Literature Review” (2020) 5:8 BMJ Glob Health.
Ahmad, Jamaluddin, “Local Government Bureaucracy and Implementation of Total Quality Management in Free Education Services in South Sulawesi Province” in MA Suhaini, M Saleh, & MA Sudiyono, eds, Indones Proceeding Int Conf Fundam Implement Educ (Yogyakarta: Yogyakarta State University, 2014) 127.
Alm, James & Sri Mulyani Indrawati, “Decentralization and local government borrowing in Indonesia” in Reforming Intergov Fisc Relat Rebuilding Indones (Edward Elgar Publishing Ltd., 2003) 234.
Bachri, Syabbul, “The Differences of Men’s and Women’s Shares in Islamic Inheritance Law Defense to Criticism and Blasphemy” (2022) 22:1 Nurani J Kaji Syariah Dan Masy 17–30.
Banaji, Mahzarin R & Anthony G Greenwald, Blindspot: Hidden biases of good people, Blindspot: Hidden biases of good people (New York: Bantam, 2013).
Beauregard, Katrine & Jill Sheppard, “Antiwomen But Proquota: Disaggregating Sexism and Support for Gender Quota Policies” (2021) 42:2 Polit Psychol 219–237.
Behrman, Julia, Ruth Meinzen-Dick & Agnes Quisumbing, “The gender implications of large-scale land deals” (2011) 39:1 J Peasant Stud 49–79.
Bidisha, Mahanta & Purusottam Nayak, Munich Personal RePEc Archive Gender Disparity and Women Empowerment in Assam Gender Disparity and Women Empowerment in Assam (2015).
Bonfert, Anna Tabitha et al, Leveraging Gender Data to Accelerate Gender Equality (Washington, DC: World Bank, 2023).
Boyne, George A et al, “Best value - Total quality management for local government?” (2002) 22:3 Public Money Manag 9–16.
Bradford, Anu & Omri Ben-Shahar, “Efficient Enforcement in International Law” (2012) 12:2 Chic J Int Law.
Buckingham, Susan, “Gender and Climate Change: Impacts, Science, Policy” (2016) 24:1 Gend Dev 151–152.
Carlarne, Cinnamon P & Jd Colavecchio, “Balancing Equity and Effectiveness: The Paris Agreement & The Future of International Climate Change Law” (2019) 27 Environ Law J.
Carnegie, M et al, “Gender, decision-making and farm practice change: An action learning intervention in Myanmar” (2020) 78 J Rural Stud 503–515.
Castaño, Ana M, Yolanda Fontanil & Antonio Garcia-Izquierdo, “‘Why Can’t I Become a Manager?’-A Systematic Review of Gender Stereotypes and Organizational Discrimination” (2019) 16:10 Int J Environ Res Public Health.
Chatun, Sri, “The Elusive 30%: Analyzing the Barriers to Female Representation in the Indonesian Parliament for East Nusa Tenggara (NTT)” (2023) KnE Soc Sci 675–687.
Cislaghi, Beniamino & Lori Heise, “Gender norms and social norms: differences, similarities and why they matter in prevention science” (2020) 42:2 Sociol Health Illn 407–422.
Cooper, Davina, “Local Government Legal Consciousness in the Shadow of Juridification” (1995) 22:4 J Law Soc 506–526.
Cotula, Lorenzo, “Land, Property and Sovereignty in International Law” (2016) J Int’l Comp L.
———, “Securing Land Rights in Africa – Trends in National and International Law” in Jan Michiel Otto & André Hoekema, eds, Fair Land Gov Leg Land Rights Rural Dev (Leiden University Press, 2012).
Crenshaw, Kimberle, “Mapping the Margins: Intersectionality, Identity Politics, and Violence against Women of Color” (1991) 43:6 Stanford Law Rev 1241–1299.
Dahlerup, Drude, “Gender Quotas - Controversial But Trendy” (2008) 10:3 Int Fem J Polit 322–328.
Deininger, Klaus, Aparajita Goyal & Hari Nagarajan, “Inheritance Law Reform and Women’s Access to Capital: Evidence from India’s Hindu Succession Act” (2010) World Bank Policy Res Work Pap No 5338.
Deshpande, Manali & Harold Kerbo, “History of the Indian Caste System and its Impact on India Today” (2010) Soc Sci.
Dhenge, S A et al, “Gender attitude towards environmental protection: a comparative survey during COVID-19 lockdown situation” (2022) 24:12 Environ Dev Sustain 13841–13886.
Dinar, Humera, “Women-Led Businesses: An Ethnographic Study of Gendered Entrepreneurship in Gilgit-Baltistan, Pakistan” (2020) 15:3 J South Asian Dev 398–414.
Doss, Cheryl & Ruth Meinzen-Dick, “Land tenure security for women: A conceptual framework” (2020) 99 Land Use Policy.
Doussis, Emmanuella & John Kenneth Galbraith, “Does International Environmental Law Matter in Sustainable Development?” in “Gaps” Int Environ Law Epoch Anthr Glob Environ Pact Rescue (2019).
Dwiputrianti, Septiana, “Challenges With Implementation Of The Merit System In The Open Recruitment Of Government High Positions: The Case In Indonesia” (2018) Adv Soc Sci Educ Humanit Res 191.
Ekesa, Beatrice et al, “Relationships between Land Tenure Insecurity, Agrobiodiversity, and Dietary Diversity of Women of Reproductive age: Evidence from Acholi and Teso subregions of Uganda” (2020) 16 Matern Child Nutr.
Enceng, Liestyodono Bi & Mw Purwaningdyah, “Meningkatkan Kompetensi Aparatur Pemerintah Daerah dalam Mewujudkan Good Governance” (2008) 2:1 Pus Pengkaj Dan Penelit Kepegawai BKN.
Espinosa, Deborah, “Secure Land Tenure: Food Security Depends on It” (2019) 3 Gates Open Res.
Farber, Daniel A, ed, “The Implementation Gap in Environmental Law” (2016) 16 J Korean Law.
Fernandez, Juan & Celia Valiente, “Gender quotas and public demand for increasing women’s representation in politics: an analysis of 28 European countries” (2021) 13:3 Eur Polit Sci Rev 1–20.
Figueiredo, Patricia & Patricia E Perkins, “Women and water management in times of climate change: participatory and inclusive processes” (2013) 60 J Clean Prod 188–194.
Fitzmaurice, Malgosia, “Environmental Compliance Control” (2018) 8:2 Wroclaw Rev Law Adm Econ 372–394.
Fox, Sean & Allan Macleod, “Localizing the SDGs in cities: reflections from an action research project in Bristol, UK” (2023) 44:3 Urban Geogr 517–537.
Grown, Caren, Tony Addison & Finn Tarp, “Aid for Gender Equality and Development: Lessons and Challenges” (2016) 28:3 J Int Dev 311–319.
Gunawan, Juniati, Paulina Permatasari & Carol Tilt, “Sustainable development goal disclosures: Do they support responsible consumption and production?” (2020) 246 J Clean Prod.
Gupta, Geeta Rao et al, “Gender equality and gender norms: framing the opportunities for health” (2023) Lancet Comm Peac Soc Health Equity Gend Equal.
Guzman, Andrew, “International Law: A Compliance Based Theory” (2002) 90:6 Calif Law Rev.
Hager, Anselm & Hanno Hilbig, “Do Inheritance Customs Affect Political and Social Inequality?” (2019) 63:4 Am J Polit Sci 758–773.
Handler, Antonia, “The New Sovereignty: Compliance with International Regulatory Agreements” (1995) 11 Yearb Int Environ Law 1–43.
Hebo, Mamo & Getaneh Mahari, “Land Tenure Reforms and Women’s Land Rights in Plural ‘Legal’ and Cultural Settings: A Comparative Study of the Arsii Oromo and Dorze-Gamo, Ethiopia” (2022) 44:1 Ethiop J Dev Res 39–76.
Hepp, Paula, Claire Somerville & Bettina Borisch, “Accelerating the United Nation’s 2030 Global Agenda: Why Prioritization of the Gender Goal is Essential” (2019) 10:4 Glob Policy 677–685.
Hillman, Ben, “The Limits of Gender Quotas: Women’s Parliamentary Representation in Indonesia” (2018) 48:2 J Contemp Asia 322–338.
Hodgson, Stephen, Cormac Cullinan & Karen Campbell, Land Ownership and Foreigners: A Comparative Analysis of Regulatory Approaches to the Acquisition and Use of Land by Foreigners (FAO Legal Papers Online, 1999).
Hole, David G et al, “Make nature’s role visible to achieve the SDGs” (2022) 5 Glob Sustain.
Howse, Robert & Ruti Teitel, “Beyond Compliance: Rethinking Why International Law Really Matters” (2010) 1:2 Glob Policy 127–136.
Irawati, Irawati et al, “The Customary Law of the Communal Property and Sustainability in Coping with the Economic Impact of Covid-19 in Minangkabau Indigenous Peoples, Indonesia” (2024) 12:1 J Law Sustain Dev.
Jain, Charu, “Women’s land ownership in India: Evidence from digital land records” (2023) 133 Land Use Policy 106835.
Jenichen, Anne, “Visible Minority Women in German Politics: Between Discrimination and Targeted Recruitment” (2020) 29:4 Ger Polit 545–563.
Johnson, Lise, Lisa Sachs & Nathan Lobel, “Aligning International Investment Agreements with the Sustainable Development Goals” (2019) 58 Columbia J Transnatl Law.
Jokinen, Jasmiina, Human Rights Abuses of Transnational Corporations under International Law-On the Legal Loopholes University of Helsinki., 2016) [unpublished].
Jolly, Stellina & KSRoshan Menon, “Climate Change, Disasters and Gender Resilience: A Legal Analysis from India” (2019) 62:4 J Indian Law Inst 420–438.
Juwana, Hikmahanto, “Teaching International Law in Indonesia” (2001) 5 Singap J Int Comp Law 412.
Kabaseke, Charlotte, “Gender responsive climate financing as a strategy to climate change mitigation and adaptation: a legal analysis” (2023) 2:2 Kabale Univ Interdiscip Res J KURJ 77–88.
Kabaseke, Charlotte,———, “Legal Recognition of Women’s Role in Combating Desertification in Africa: The Case for Uganda” in Clim Change Manag (Springer, 2020).
Kameri-Mbote, Patricia, “The Land Has Its Owners! Gender Issues in Land Tenure under Customary Law in Kenya” (2005) UNDP-Int Land Coalit Workshop Land Rights Afr Dev.
Kim, Eun Mee, “Gender and the Sustainable Development Goals” (2017) 17:2 Glob Soc Policy 239–244.
Kim, Rakhyun E, “The Nexus between International Law and the Sustainable Development Goals” (2016) 25:1 Rev Eur Community Int Environ Law 15–26.
Kjellberg, Francesco, “The Changing Values of Local Government” (1995) 540 Ann Am Acad Pol Soc Sci 40–50.
Koehler, Gabriele, “Tapping the Sustainable Development Goals for progressive gender equity and equality policy?” (2016) 24 Gend Dev 1–16.
Koh, Niak Sian, Claudia Ituarte-Lima & Thomas Hahn, “Mind the Compliance Gap: How Insights from International Human Rights Mechanisms Can Help to Implement the Convention on Biological Diversity” (2022) 11:1 Transnatl Environ Law 39–67.
Konte, Maty & Nyasha Tirivayi, eds, Women and Sustainable Human Development: Empowering Women in Africa, Gender, Development and Social Change (Springer International Publishing, 2020).
Krajewski, Markus, Andreas Frewer & Manfred L Pirner, “Interdisciplinary Studies in Human Rights” (2020) 5 Springer Open.
Krook, Mona Lena & Medha Nanivadekar, “Gender Quotas II Are Quotas a Good Idea? The Indian Experience with Reserved Seats for Women” (2006) 2:1 Polit Gend 101–128.
Kumari, Sarita, “Women Inheritance Rights In India: Some Reflections” (2019) 6:1 Int J Res Anal Rev.
Kusi, Nancy Kankam et al, “Discourse on women and land tenure in Ghana: does a matrilineal land tenure system make a difference for women?” (2021) Land Gov Gend Tenure-Gend Nexus Land Manag Land Policy 129–142.
Kusumasari, Bevaola & Quamrul Alam, “Bridging the gaps: The role of local government capability and the management of a natural disaster in Bantul, Indonesia” (2012) 60:2 Nat Hazards 761–779.
Lau, Jacqueline et al, “Gender equality in climate policy and practice hindered by assumptions” (2021) 11:3 Nat Clim Change 186–192.
Le, Kien & My Nguyen, “How Education Empowers Women in Developing Countries” (2020) BE J Econ Anal Policy.
Leslie, Isaac Sohn, Jaclyn Wypler & Michael Mayerfeld Bell, “Relational Agriculture: Gender, Sexuality, and Sustainability in U.S. Farming” (2019) 32:8 Soc Nat Resour 853–874.
Levien, Michael, “Gender and Dispossession: A Comparative Analysis” (2017) 44:6 J Peasant Stud 1111–1134.
Lowndes, Vivien, “How Are Political Institutions Gendered?” (2020) 68:3 Polit Stud 543–564.
Meuleman, Louis, “Public Administration and Governance for the SDGs: Navigating between Change and Stability” (2021) 13:11 Sustainability 5914.
Minow, Martha, “Equality Vs. Equity” (2021) 1 Am J Law Equal 167–193.
Morita, Kanako, Mahesti Okitasari & Hiromi Masuda, “Analysis of national and local governance systems to achieve the sustainable development goals: case studies of Japan and Indonesia” (2020) 15:1 Sustain Sci 179–202.
Namubiru-Mwaura, Evelyn, “Land Tenure and Gender : Approaches and Challenges for Strengthening Rural Women’s Land Rights” (2014) 6 Women’s Voice Agency Particip Res Ser (Women’s Voice, Agency, & Participation Research Series) .
Noori, Seyed Masoud & Soheila Louyeh, “When Environmental Obligations Collide with State Sovereignty: An International and Sharia Law Perspective” (2020) 41:1 Consensus.
Norgaard, Kari & Richard York, “Gender Equality and State Environmentalism” (2005) 19:4 Gend Soc 506–522.
Obydenkova, Anastassia & Rauf Salahodjaev, “Intelligence, democracy, and international environmental commitment” (2016) 147:1 Environ Res 82–88.
Oktarina, Tri Nurmega & Anisa Yulianti, “The Role of Women in Sustainable Development and Environmental Protection: A Discourse of Ecofeminisme in Indonesia” (2022) 1:2 Indones J Environ Law Sustain Dev 107–138.
Oktaviandra, Surya, “Closing Legal Loopholes on Indonesia Investment Law in Digital Age” (2022) 15:1 Indones Law J 19–36.
———, “Creating a Balance in Bilateral Investment Treaty: A Perspective from Indonesia” (2022) 4:1 Andalas Int J Socio-Humanit 8–15.
———, “Penataan Ulang Pengaturan Penanaman Modal Asing di Indonesia Melalui Momentum Pembangunan Ibu Kota Negara (Remodeling of Foreign Investment Regulations in Indonesia Through the National Capital Development Momentum)” (2022) 52:1 Maj Huk Nas 127–145.
———, “Three Arguments to Support International Binding Treaty on Business and Human Rights” (2022) 13:2 J HAM 253.
Pathania, Sudershan Kumar, “Sustainable Development Goal: Gender Equality for Women’s Empowerment and Human Rights” (2017) 5:86 Int J Res 72–82.
Pavoni, Riccardo & Dario Piselli, “The Sustainable Development Goals and International Environmental Law: Normative Value and Challenges for Implementation” (2016) 13:26 Veredas Direito Direito Ambient E Desenvolv Sustentável 13–60.
Phiri, Austin T et al, “A review of gender inclusivity in agriculture and natural resources management under the changing climate in sub-Saharan Africa” (2022) 8:1 Cogent Soc Sci.
Polzer, Tobias, Isabella M Nolte & Johann Seiwald, “Gender budgeting in public financial management: a literature review and research agenda” (2023) 89:2 Int Rev Adm Sci 450–466.
Rai, Anuradha, “Land Rights of Women in India: How Much Has Changed After 2005” in Sustain Sci Asia Afr (Springer, 2023).
Rakhmawanto, Ajib, Budiman Rusli & Sintaningrum Sintaningrum, “Merit System Selection for Pratama Senior Executive Service State Civil Apparatus in Central Java Provincial Government” (2019) 11:1 J Bina Praja 31–41.
Ranjan, Prabhash & Pushkar Anand, “Determination of Indirect Expropriation and Doctrine of Police Power in International Investment Law: A Critical Appraisal” (2016) Leila Choukroune Ed Judg State Int Trade Invest Law 2016 127–151.
Ravnborg, Helle Munk et al, “Land Governance, Gender Equality and Development: Past Achievements and Remaining Challenges” (2016) 28:3 J Int Dev 412–427.
Razavi, Shahra, “The 2030 Agenda: challenges of implementation to attain gender equality and women’s rights” (2016) 24:1 Gend Dev 25–41.
Rehn, Elisabeth & Ellen Johnson-Sirleaf, Women, War Peace : The Independent Experts’ Assessment on the Impact of Armed Conflict on Women and Women’s Role in Peace Building (UNIFEM, 2002).
Rose, Gregory L, “Gaps in the Implementation of Environmental Law at the National, Regional and Global Level” in World Congr Justice Gov Law Environ Sustain (2011).
Sadat, Anwar, “Knowledge Management to Improve Local Government Services: Knowledge Management” (2021) 2:3 Int J Sci Technol Amp Manag 582–591.
Samson, Danny & Mile Terziovski, “The relationship between total quality management practices and operational performance” (1999) 17:4 J Oper Manag 393–409.
Savaresi, Annalisa & Joanne Scott, “Implementing the Paris Agreement: Lessons from the Global Human Rights Regime” (2019) 9:3 Clim Law 159–164.
Setiawan, Agustina, Widuri Wulandari & Siti Munawaroh, “Kemampuan Aparatur Pemerintah Desa dalam Pengelolaan Keuangan Desa di Desa Cempakamekar Kecamatan Padalarang Kabupaten Bandung Barat” (2022) 8:1 Moderat J Ilm Ilmu Pemerintah 171–183.
Singirankabo, Uwacu Alban & Maurits Willem Ertsen, “Relations between Land Tenure Security and Agricultural Productivity: Exploring the Effect of Land Registration” (2020) 9:5 Land 1–18.
Siscawati, Mia et al, “Gender Equality and Women Empowerment in The National Development of Indonesia” (2020) J Strateg Glob Stud.
Sjaf, Sofyan et al, “Measuring Achievement of Sustainable Development Goals in Rural Area: A Case Study of Sukamantri Village in Bogor District, West Java, Indonesia” (2021) 9:2 Sodality J Sosiol Pedesaan.
Smith, Jessica M, Lauren Olosky & Jennifer Grosman Fernández, “The Climate-Gender-Conflict Nexus Amplifying Women’s Contributions at the Grassroots”, (2021), online: GIWPS.
Sparkman, Gregg, Lauren Howe & Greg Walton, “How social norms are often a barrier to addressing climate change but can be part of the solution” (2021) 5:4 Behav Public Policy 528–555.
Supraptiningsih, Umi et al, “Inequality as a cultural construction: Women’s access to land rights in Madurese society” (2023) 9:1 Cogent Soc Sci.
Syahirah, Sharifah, “A Gender Quota Policy Implementation and Women Empowerment in The Malaysian Public Sector” (2016) 2:1 Aust J Sustain Bus Soc Vol 2 No 1 March 2016 59–68.
United Nations, Technical Note-SDG 5 Global, Regional and Country Assessments. (2022).
———, The Sustainable Development Goals Report 2023 - Special Edition, by United Nations (United Nations, 2023).
———, Women And Elections. United Nations, by United Nations (United Nations, 2005).
Van Der Marel, Eva Romée, “Trading Plastic Waste in a Global Economy: Soundly Regulated by the Basel Convention?” (2022) 34:3 J Environ Law 477–497.
Von Stein, Jana, Compliance with International Law (Oxford Research Encyclopedia of International Studies, 2010).
Wolniak, Radosław, Process Management Level In Local Government (Philadelphia: CreateSpace Independent Publishing Platform, 2018).
Zetterberg, Pär, “The Downside of Gender Quotas?1 Institutional Constraints on Women in Mexican State Legislatures” (2008) 61:3 Parliam Aff 442–460.
Aftab, Wafa et al, “Implementation of Health and Health-Related Sustainable Development Goals: Progress, Challenges and Opportunities-a Systematic Literature Review” (2020) 5:8 BMJ Glob Health.
Ahmad, Jamaluddin, “Local Government Bureaucracy and Implementation of Total Quality Management in Free Education Services in South Sulawesi Province” in MA Suhaini, M Saleh, & MA Sudiyono, eds, Indones Proceeding Int Conf Fundam Implement Educ (Yogyakarta: Yogyakarta State University, 2014) 127.
Alm, James & Sri Mulyani Indrawati, “Decentralization and local government borrowing in Indonesia” in Reforming Intergov Fisc Relat Rebuilding Indones (Edward Elgar Publishing Ltd., 2003) 234.
Bachri, Syabbul, “The Differences of Men’s and Women’s Shares in Islamic Inheritance Law Defense to Criticism and Blasphemy” (2022) 22:1 Nurani J Kaji Syariah Dan Masy 17–30.
Banaji, Mahzarin R & Anthony G Greenwald, Blindspot: Hidden biases of good people, Blindspot: Hidden biases of good people (New York: Bantam, 2013).
Beauregard, Katrine & Jill Sheppard, “Antiwomen But Proquota: Disaggregating Sexism and Support for Gender Quota Policies” (2021) 42:2 Polit Psychol 219–237.
Behrman, Julia, Ruth Meinzen-Dick & Agnes Quisumbing, “The gender implications of large-scale land deals” (2011) 39:1 J Peasant Stud 49–79.
Bidisha, Mahanta & Purusottam Nayak, Munich Personal RePEc Archive Gender Disparity and Women Empowerment in Assam Gender Disparity and Women Empowerment in Assam (2015).
Bonfert, Anna Tabitha et al, Leveraging Gender Data to Accelerate Gender Equality (Washington, DC: World Bank, 2023).
Boyne, George A et al, “Best value - Total quality management for local government?” (2002) 22:3 Public Money Manag 9–16.
Bradford, Anu & Omri Ben-Shahar, “Efficient Enforcement in International Law” (2012) 12:2 Chic J Int Law.
Buckingham, Susan, “Gender and Climate Change: Impacts, Science, Policy” (2016) 24:1 Gend Dev 151–152.
Carlarne, Cinnamon P & Jd Colavecchio, “Balancing Equity and Effectiveness: The Paris Agreement & The Future of International Climate Change Law” (2019) 27 Environ Law J.
Carnegie, M et al, “Gender, decision-making and farm practice change: An action learning intervention in Myanmar” (2020) 78 J Rural Stud 503–515.
Castaño, Ana M, Yolanda Fontanil & Antonio Garcia-Izquierdo, “‘Why Can’t I Become a Manager?’-A Systematic Review of Gender Stereotypes and Organizational Discrimination” (2019) 16:10 Int J Environ Res Public Health.
Chatun, Sri, “The Elusive 30%: Analyzing the Barriers to Female Representation in the Indonesian Parliament for East Nusa Tenggara (NTT)” (2023) KnE Soc Sci 675–687.
Cislaghi, Beniamino & Lori Heise, “Gender norms and social norms: differences, similarities and why they matter in prevention science” (2020) 42:2 Sociol Health Illn 407–422.
Cooper, Davina, “Local Government Legal Consciousness in the Shadow of Juridification” (1995) 22:4 J Law Soc 506–526.
Cotula, Lorenzo, “Land, Property and Sovereignty in International Law” (2016) J Int’l Comp L.
———, “Securing Land Rights in Africa – Trends in National and International Law” in Jan Michiel Otto & André Hoekema, eds, Fair Land Gov Leg Land Rights Rural Dev (Leiden University Press, 2012).
Crenshaw, Kimberle, “Mapping the Margins: Intersectionality, Identity Politics, and Violence against Women of Color” (1991) 43:6 Stanford Law Rev 1241–1299.
Dahlerup, Drude, “Gender Quotas - Controversial But Trendy” (2008) 10:3 Int Fem J Polit 322–328.
Deininger, Klaus, Aparajita Goyal & Hari Nagarajan, “Inheritance Law Reform and Women’s Access to Capital: Evidence from India’s Hindu Succession Act” (2010) World Bank Policy Res Work Pap No 5338.
Deshpande, Manali & Harold Kerbo, “History of the Indian Caste System and its Impact on India Today” (2010) Soc Sci.
Dhenge, S A et al, “Gender attitude towards environmental protection: a comparative survey during COVID-19 lockdown situation” (2022) 24:12 Environ Dev Sustain 13841–13886.
Dinar, Humera, “Women-Led Businesses: An Ethnographic Study of Gendered Entrepreneurship in Gilgit-Baltistan, Pakistan” (2020) 15:3 J South Asian Dev 398–414.
Doss, Cheryl & Ruth Meinzen-Dick, “Land tenure security for women: A conceptual framework” (2020) 99 Land Use Policy.
Doussis, Emmanuella & John Kenneth Galbraith, “Does International Environmental Law Matter in Sustainable Development?” in “Gaps” Int Environ Law Epoch Anthr Glob Environ Pact Rescue (2019).
Dwiputrianti, Septiana, “Challenges With Implementation Of The Merit System In The Open Recruitment Of Government High Positions: The Case In Indonesia” (2018) Adv Soc Sci Educ Humanit Res 191.
Ekesa, Beatrice et al, “Relationships between Land Tenure Insecurity, Agrobiodiversity, and Dietary Diversity of Women of Reproductive age: Evidence from Acholi and Teso subregions of Uganda” (2020) 16 Matern Child Nutr.
Enceng, Liestyodono Bi & Mw Purwaningdyah, “Meningkatkan Kompetensi Aparatur Pemerintah Daerah dalam Mewujudkan Good Governance” (2008) 2:1 Pus Pengkaj Dan Penelit Kepegawai BKN.
Espinosa, Deborah, “Secure Land Tenure: Food Security Depends on It” (2019) 3 Gates Open Res.
Farber, Daniel A, ed, “The Implementation Gap in Environmental Law” (2016) 16 J Korean Law.
Fernandez, Juan & Celia Valiente, “Gender quotas and public demand for increasing women’s representation in politics: an analysis of 28 European countries” (2021) 13:3 Eur Polit Sci Rev 1–20.
Figueiredo, Patricia & Patricia E Perkins, “Women and water management in times of climate change: participatory and inclusive processes” (2013) 60 J Clean Prod 188–194.
Fitzmaurice, Malgosia, “Environmental Compliance Control” (2018) 8:2 Wroclaw Rev Law Adm Econ 372–394.
Fox, Sean & Allan Macleod, “Localizing the SDGs in cities: reflections from an action research project in Bristol, UK” (2023) 44:3 Urban Geogr 517–537.
Grown, Caren, Tony Addison & Finn Tarp, “Aid for Gender Equality and Development: Lessons and Challenges” (2016) 28:3 J Int Dev 311–319.
Gunawan, Juniati, Paulina Permatasari & Carol Tilt, “Sustainable development goal disclosures: Do they support responsible consumption and production?” (2020) 246 J Clean Prod.
Gupta, Geeta Rao et al, “Gender equality and gender norms: framing the opportunities for health” (2023) Lancet Comm Peac Soc Health Equity Gend Equal.
Guzman, Andrew, “International Law: A Compliance Based Theory” (2002) 90:6 Calif Law Rev.
Hager, Anselm & Hanno Hilbig, “Do Inheritance Customs Affect Political and Social Inequality?” (2019) 63:4 Am J Polit Sci 758–773.
Handler, Antonia, “The New Sovereignty: Compliance with International Regulatory Agreements” (1995) 11 Yearb Int Environ Law 1–43.
Hebo, Mamo & Getaneh Mahari, “Land Tenure Reforms and Women’s Land Rights in Plural ‘Legal’ and Cultural Settings: A Comparative Study of the Arsii Oromo and Dorze-Gamo, Ethiopia” (2022) 44:1 Ethiop J Dev Res 39–76.
Hepp, Paula, Claire Somerville & Bettina Borisch, “Accelerating the United Nation’s 2030 Global Agenda: Why Prioritization of the Gender Goal is Essential” (2019) 10:4 Glob Policy 677–685.
Hillman, Ben, “The Limits of Gender Quotas: Women’s Parliamentary Representation in Indonesia” (2018) 48:2 J Contemp Asia 322–338.
Hodgson, Stephen, Cormac Cullinan & Karen Campbell, Land Ownership and Foreigners: A Comparative Analysis of Regulatory Approaches to the Acquisition and Use of Land by Foreigners (FAO Legal Papers Online, 1999).
Hole, David G et al, “Make nature’s role visible to achieve the SDGs” (2022) 5 Glob Sustain.
Howse, Robert & Ruti Teitel, “Beyond Compliance: Rethinking Why International Law Really Matters” (2010) 1:2 Glob Policy 127–136.
Irawati, Irawati et al, “The Customary Law of the Communal Property and Sustainability in Coping with the Economic Impact of Covid-19 in Minangkabau Indigenous Peoples, Indonesia” (2024) 12:1 J Law Sustain Dev.
Jain, Charu, “Women’s land ownership in India: Evidence from digital land records” (2023) 133 Land Use Policy 106835.
Jenichen, Anne, “Visible Minority Women in German Politics: Between Discrimination and Targeted Recruitment” (2020) 29:4 Ger Polit 545–563.
Johnson, Lise, Lisa Sachs & Nathan Lobel, “Aligning International Investment Agreements with the Sustainable Development Goals” (2019) 58 Columbia J Transnatl Law.
Jokinen, Jasmiina, Human Rights Abuses of Transnational Corporations under International Law-On the Legal Loopholes University of Helsinki., 2016) [unpublished].
Jolly, Stellina & KSRoshan Menon, “Climate Change, Disasters and Gender Resilience: A Legal Analysis from India” (2019) 62:4 J Indian Law Inst 420–438.
Juwana, Hikmahanto, “Teaching International Law in Indonesia” (2001) 5 Singap J Int Comp Law 412.
Kabaseke, Charlotte, “Gender responsive climate financing as a strategy to climate change mitigation and adaptation: a legal analysis” (2023) 2:2 Kabale Univ Interdiscip Res J KURJ 77–88.
Kabaseke, Charlotte,———, “Legal Recognition of Women’s Role in Combating Desertification in Africa: The Case for Uganda” in Clim Change Manag (Springer, 2020).
Kameri-Mbote, Patricia, “The Land Has Its Owners! Gender Issues in Land Tenure under Customary Law in Kenya” (2005) UNDP-Int Land Coalit Workshop Land Rights Afr Dev.
Kim, Eun Mee, “Gender and the Sustainable Development Goals” (2017) 17:2 Glob Soc Policy 239–244.
Kim, Rakhyun E, “The Nexus between International Law and the Sustainable Development Goals” (2016) 25:1 Rev Eur Community Int Environ Law 15–26.
Kjellberg, Francesco, “The Changing Values of Local Government” (1995) 540 Ann Am Acad Pol Soc Sci 40–50.
Koehler, Gabriele, “Tapping the Sustainable Development Goals for progressive gender equity and equality policy?” (2016) 24 Gend Dev 1–16.
Koh, Niak Sian, Claudia Ituarte-Lima & Thomas Hahn, “Mind the Compliance Gap: How Insights from International Human Rights Mechanisms Can Help to Implement the Convention on Biological Diversity” (2022) 11:1 Transnatl Environ Law 39–67.
Konte, Maty & Nyasha Tirivayi, eds, Women and Sustainable Human Development: Empowering Women in Africa, Gender, Development and Social Change (Springer International Publishing, 2020).
Krajewski, Markus, Andreas Frewer & Manfred L Pirner, “Interdisciplinary Studies in Human Rights” (2020) 5 Springer Open.
Krook, Mona Lena & Medha Nanivadekar, “Gender Quotas II Are Quotas a Good Idea? The Indian Experience with Reserved Seats for Women” (2006) 2:1 Polit Gend 101–128.
Kumari, Sarita, “Women Inheritance Rights In India: Some Reflections” (2019) 6:1 Int J Res Anal Rev.
Kusi, Nancy Kankam et al, “Discourse on women and land tenure in Ghana: does a matrilineal land tenure system make a difference for women?” (2021) Land Gov Gend Tenure-Gend Nexus Land Manag Land Policy 129–142.
Kusumasari, Bevaola & Quamrul Alam, “Bridging the gaps: The role of local government capability and the management of a natural disaster in Bantul, Indonesia” (2012) 60:2 Nat Hazards 761–779.
Lau, Jacqueline et al, “Gender equality in climate policy and practice hindered by assumptions” (2021) 11:3 Nat Clim Change 186–192.
Le, Kien & My Nguyen, “How Education Empowers Women in Developing Countries” (2020) BE J Econ Anal Policy.
Leslie, Isaac Sohn, Jaclyn Wypler & Michael Mayerfeld Bell, “Relational Agriculture: Gender, Sexuality, and Sustainability in U.S. Farming” (2019) 32:8 Soc Nat Resour 853–874.
Levien, Michael, “Gender and Dispossession: A Comparative Analysis” (2017) 44:6 J Peasant Stud 1111–1134.
Lowndes, Vivien, “How Are Political Institutions Gendered?” (2020) 68:3 Polit Stud 543–564.
Meuleman, Louis, “Public Administration and Governance for the SDGs: Navigating between Change and Stability” (2021) 13:11 Sustainability 5914.
Minow, Martha, “Equality Vs. Equity” (2021) 1 Am J Law Equal 167–193.
Morita, Kanako, Mahesti Okitasari & Hiromi Masuda, “Analysis of national and local governance systems to achieve the sustainable development goals: case studies of Japan and Indonesia” (2020) 15:1 Sustain Sci 179–202.
Namubiru-Mwaura, Evelyn, “Land Tenure and Gender : Approaches and Challenges for Strengthening Rural Women’s Land Rights” (2014) 6 Women’s Voice Agency Particip Res Ser (Women’s Voice, Agency, & Participation Research Series) .
Noori, Seyed Masoud & Soheila Louyeh, “When Environmental Obligations Collide with State Sovereignty: An International and Sharia Law Perspective” (2020) 41:1 Consensus.
Norgaard, Kari & Richard York, “Gender Equality and State Environmentalism” (2005) 19:4 Gend Soc 506–522.
Obydenkova, Anastassia & Rauf Salahodjaev, “Intelligence, democracy, and international environmental commitment” (2016) 147:1 Environ Res 82–88.
Oktarina, Tri Nurmega & Anisa Yulianti, “The Role of Women in Sustainable Development and Environmental Protection: A Discourse of Ecofeminisme in Indonesia” (2022) 1:2 Indones J Environ Law Sustain Dev 107–138.
Oktaviandra, Surya, “Closing Legal Loopholes on Indonesia Investment Law in Digital Age” (2022) 15:1 Indones Law J 19–36.
———, “Creating a Balance in Bilateral Investment Treaty: A Perspective from Indonesia” (2022) 4:1 Andalas Int J Socio-Humanit 8–15.
———, “Penataan Ulang Pengaturan Penanaman Modal Asing di Indonesia Melalui Momentum Pembangunan Ibu Kota Negara (Remodeling of Foreign Investment Regulations in Indonesia Through the National Capital Development Momentum)” (2022) 52:1 Maj Huk Nas 127–145.
———, “Three Arguments to Support International Binding Treaty on Business and Human Rights” (2022) 13:2 J HAM 253.
Pathania, Sudershan Kumar, “Sustainable Development Goal: Gender Equality for Women’s Empowerment and Human Rights” (2017) 5:86 Int J Res 72–82.
Pavoni, Riccardo & Dario Piselli, “The Sustainable Development Goals and International Environmental Law: Normative Value and Challenges for Implementation” (2016) 13:26 Veredas Direito Direito Ambient E Desenvolv Sustentável 13–60.
Phiri, Austin T et al, “A review of gender inclusivity in agriculture and natural resources management under the changing climate in sub-Saharan Africa” (2022) 8:1 Cogent Soc Sci.
Polzer, Tobias, Isabella M Nolte & Johann Seiwald, “Gender budgeting in public financial management: a literature review and research agenda” (2023) 89:2 Int Rev Adm Sci 450–466.
Rai, Anuradha, “Land Rights of Women in India: How Much Has Changed After 2005” in Sustain Sci Asia Afr (Springer, 2023).
Rakhmawanto, Ajib, Budiman Rusli & Sintaningrum Sintaningrum, “Merit System Selection for Pratama Senior Executive Service State Civil Apparatus in Central Java Provincial Government” (2019) 11:1 J Bina Praja 31–41.
Ranjan, Prabhash & Pushkar Anand, “Determination of Indirect Expropriation and Doctrine of Police Power in International Investment Law: A Critical Appraisal” (2016) Leila Choukroune Ed Judg State Int Trade Invest Law 2016 127–151.
Ravnborg, Helle Munk et al, “Land Governance, Gender Equality and Development: Past Achievements and Remaining Challenges” (2016) 28:3 J Int Dev 412–427.
Razavi, Shahra, “The 2030 Agenda: challenges of implementation to attain gender equality and women’s rights” (2016) 24:1 Gend Dev 25–41.
Rehn, Elisabeth & Ellen Johnson-Sirleaf, Women, War Peace : The Independent Experts’ Assessment on the Impact of Armed Conflict on Women and Women’s Role in Peace Building (UNIFEM, 2002).
Rose, Gregory L, “Gaps in the Implementation of Environmental Law at the National, Regional and Global Level” in World Congr Justice Gov Law Environ Sustain (2011).
Sadat, Anwar, “Knowledge Management to Improve Local Government Services: Knowledge Management” (2021) 2:3 Int J Sci Technol Amp Manag 582–591.
Samson, Danny & Mile Terziovski, “The relationship between total quality management practices and operational performance” (1999) 17:4 J Oper Manag 393–409.
Savaresi, Annalisa & Joanne Scott, “Implementing the Paris Agreement: Lessons from the Global Human Rights Regime” (2019) 9:3 Clim Law 159–164.
Setiawan, Agustina, Widuri Wulandari & Siti Munawaroh, “Kemampuan Aparatur Pemerintah Desa dalam Pengelolaan Keuangan Desa di Desa Cempakamekar Kecamatan Padalarang Kabupaten Bandung Barat” (2022) 8:1 Moderat J Ilm Ilmu Pemerintah 171–183.
Singirankabo, Uwacu Alban & Maurits Willem Ertsen, “Relations between Land Tenure Security and Agricultural Productivity: Exploring the Effect of Land Registration” (2020) 9:5 Land 1–18.
Siscawati, Mia et al, “Gender Equality and Women Empowerment in The National Development of Indonesia” (2020) J Strateg Glob Stud.
Sjaf, Sofyan et al, “Measuring Achievement of Sustainable Development Goals in Rural Area: A Case Study of Sukamantri Village in Bogor District, West Java, Indonesia” (2021) 9:2 Sodality J Sosiol Pedesaan.
Smith, Jessica M, Lauren Olosky & Jennifer Grosman Fernández, “The Climate-Gender-Conflict Nexus Amplifying Women’s Contributions at the Grassroots”, (2021), online: GIWPS.
Sparkman, Gregg, Lauren Howe & Greg Walton, “How social norms are often a barrier to addressing climate change but can be part of the solution” (2021) 5:4 Behav Public Policy 528–555.
Supraptiningsih, Umi et al, “Inequality as a cultural construction: Women’s access to land rights in Madurese society” (2023) 9:1 Cogent Soc Sci.
Syahirah, Sharifah, “A Gender Quota Policy Implementation and Women Empowerment in The Malaysian Public Sector” (2016) 2:1 Aust J Sustain Bus Soc Vol 2 No 1 March 2016 59–68.
United Nations, Technical Note-SDG 5 Global, Regional and Country Assessments. (2022).
———, The Sustainable Development Goals Report 2023 - Special Edition, by United Nations (United Nations, 2023).
———, Women And Elections. United Nations, by United Nations (United Nations, 2005).
Van Der Marel, Eva Romée, “Trading Plastic Waste in a Global Economy: Soundly Regulated by the Basel Convention?” (2022) 34:3 J Environ Law 477–497.
Von Stein, Jana, Compliance with International Law (Oxford Research Encyclopedia of International Studies, 2010).
Wolniak, Radosław, Process Management Level In Local Government (Philadelphia: CreateSpace Independent Publishing Platform, 2018).
Zetterberg, Pär, “The Downside of Gender Quotas?1 Institutional Constraints on Women in Mexican State Legislatures” (2008) 61:3 Parliam Aff 442–460.
Published
2024-06-29
How to Cite
OKTAVIANDRA, Surya; ARZA, Putri Aulia.
From International Regulation to Local Implementation.
Journal of Southeast Asian Human Rights, [S.l.], v. 8, n. 1, p. 173-212, june 2024.
ISSN 2599-2147.
Available at: <https://jurnal.unej.ac.id/index.php/JSEAHR/article/view/44031>. Date accessed: 19 dec. 2024.
doi: https://doi.org/10.19184/jseahr.v8i1.44031.
Section
Articles
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
