Unsafe River Bank Houses? A Legal Reflection on Issues of Freedom from Poverty, Development Programmes and Accountability Mechanisms in Indonesia
Millions of the most deprived people worldwide live in slums with a lack of access to adequate water, hygiene and sanitation. Inadequate housing and living conditions increase vulnerability to other problems. For example, people living on the river banks in Jakarta regularly experience flooding due to adverse environmental conditions. Not only do the river bank settlements suffer from floods, but also other settlements as well as offices in Jakarta encounter similar effects. These regular floods cause billions of Indonesian Rupiah’s (IDR) in damages annually. As part of flood prevention programmes, the Jakarta government has evacuated and emptied the river bank settlements and has relocated the residents to rented, public high-rise housing provided by the municipality. This article will not address the legal issues of the relocation. Rather, it will examine whether relocation and resettlement due to development programmes can be addressed from a different perspective focusing on human rights as a means to eliminate poverty. It will also investigate the available accountability mechanisms at both the international and national level. Furthermore, it will assess whether these mechanisms can be employed to address the effect of development programmes which disproportionally affect people living on river banks. This study will use the classic legal research method, i.e. the normative legal method, to answer the research questions. In addition, it will also employ the human rights-based approach in assessing the regulation and policies adopted by the Indonesian authorities. The final part of this article will provide conclusions and recommendations for policymakers to address the societal problems by employing the human rights approach in tackling poverty and reducing the negative impacts of developments.
The 1945 Constitution of the Republic of Indonesia
Law No. 39/1999 on Hak Asasi Manusia (Human Rights Law).
Law No. 17 /2007 on Pembangunan Menengah Jangka Panjang Nasional (the National Long-Term Development Plan) 2005-2025.
Law No. 28/1999 on Penyelenggaraan Negara yang Bersih dan Bebas dari Korupsi, Kolusi dan Nepotisme (Clean Governance and Corruption, Collusions and Nepotism Free).
Law No 48/2009 on Kekuasaan Kehakiman (Judicial Power).
Law 51/2009 on Perubahan kedua Undang Undang No. 5/1986 tentang Pengadilan Tata Usaha Negara (the 2nd Amendment of Law 5/1986 on Administrative Court).
Law No 2/2012 on Pengadaan Tanah Bagi Pembangunan Untuk Kepentingan Umum (Land Procurement for Development of Public Interest).
Presidential Regulation Number 15 of 2010 on Percepatan Penanggulangan Kemiskinan (Acceleration on Poverty Countermeasures).
Presidential Regulation 7/2005 on Rencana Pembangunan Jangka Menengah Nasional (the National Medium-Term Development Plan) 2004-2009.
Regulation of the Menteri Pendayagunaan Aparatur Negara (Ministry of Administrative) No. 13/2009 on Pedoman Peningkatan Kualitas Pelayanan Publik dengan Partisipasi Masyarakat (Guidelines on the Improvement of Quality in Service Delivery with Public Participation).
Governor Regulation of DKI Jakarta No. 111/2014 on Mekanisme Penghunian Rumah Susun Sederhana Sewa (Renting Mechanism of the Rented Public Housing).
Local Regulation of Kota Surabaya No. 2/2010 on Pemakaian Rumah Susun (The Usage of Multi-storey Housing).
Mayor Regulation of Yogyakarta No. 44/2009 on Pengelolaan Rumah Susun Sederhana Sewa Milik Pemerintah Kota Yogyakarta (the Management of Rented Multi-storey Housing owned by the Jogjakarta Municipality).
Galuh Radiah et al. v. Gubernur Provinsi Daerah Khusus Ibu Kota Jakarta (Jakarta Administrative Court, 25 April 2016, judgment) 59/G/2016/PTUN-JKT online: Mahkamah Agung Republik Indonesia - MARI (The Indonesian Supreme Court)
Gubernur Provinsi Daerah Khusus Ibu Kota Jakarta v. Galuh Radiani et al (MARI, 23 August 2016, judgment) 267 K/TUN/2016, online: MARI
C. International Materials
Universal Declaration on Human Rights (adopted on 10 December 1948) UN Doc: GA Res. 217 A (III) online: OHCHR
International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (adopted on 16 December 1966, entered into force 3 January 1976) 993 UNTS (ICESCR).
The Second Optional Protocol on Individual Complaints (10 December 2008) UN. Doc. A/RES/63/117, online: OHCHR
Vienna Declaration and Programme of Action, adopted by the World Conference on Human Rights on 25 June 1993, UN Doc: A/CONF.157/23.
United Nations Economic and Social Council (ESC), Report of the Independent Expert on Human rights and Extreme Poverty Arjun Sengupta, UN Doc: E/CN.4/2006/43; 2 March 2006.
United Nations General Assembly, the Basic Principles and Guidelines on Development-Based Evictions and Displacement, UN Doc A/HRC/4/18 (5 February 2007)
United Nations General Assembly (UNGA), Report of the Special Rapporteur on adequate housing as a component of the right to an adequate standard of living, and on the right to non-discrimination in this context, Raquel Rolnik, UN Doc. A/HRC/25/54/Add.1, 26 December 2013.
D. Books, Periodicals and Newspapers
Aji, Priasto. “Summary of Indonesia’s Poverty Analysis”, ADB Papers Indonesia (2015).
Alston, Philip. “Ships Passing in the Night: The Current State of the Human Rights and Development Debate seen through the Lens of the Millennium Development Goals” (2005) 27:3 Hum Rights Q 755, online:
Badan Perencanan Pembangunan Nasional (BAPPENAS), Badan Pusat Statistik (BPS) and United Nations Population Fund (UNFPA), Proyeksi Penduduk Indonesia (Indonesia Population Projection) 2010-2035 (Jakarta, Badan Pusat Statistik, 2013) online: BAPPENAS
Badan Pusat Statistik, Dasar-dasar Analisis Kemiskinan (Jakarta, Indonesian Statistic Agency and World Bank Institute, Jakarta, 2002).
Belasminus, Robertus. “Warga Kampung Pulo yang Direlokasi ke Rusun Kesulitan Bayar Sewa”, Kompas (31 March 2016) online: Kompas
Bovens, Mark. “Analysing and Assessing Accountability: A Conceptual Framework” (2007) 13:4 Eur Law J 447, online:
———. “Two concepts of accountability: Accountability as a virtue and as a Mechanism” (2010) 33:5 West Eur Polit 946.
Budiardjo, Miriam. Menggapai kedaulatan Untuk Rakyat (Bandung: Mizan, 1998).
Krina P., Dra. Loina Lalolo. Indikator & Alat Ukur Prinsip Akuntabilitas, Transparansi & Partisipasi, online: Bakti Digital Library
Campbell, Tom. " Poverty as a Violation of Human Rights: Inhumanity or Injustice?"in Thomas Pogge, ed, Free from Poverty as a Human Right who owes what to very poor? (Oxford: UNESCO and Oxford University Press, 2007
Chong, Daniel P L. “NGOs and Freedom from Poverty” in Free from Poverty NGOs Hum Rights Prax (Pensylvania: Univeristy of Pensylvania Press, 2010) 1.
Das, Ashok. “A City of Two Tales: Shelter and Migrants Surabaya” (2017) 8:1 Environtment Urban Asia 1.
Day, Patricia and Rudolf Klein, Accountabilities: Five Public Services (London: Tavistock Publications, 1987).
Direktorat Jenderal Cipta Karya, Rusunawa: Komitmen Bersama Penanganan Pemukiman Kumuh, Kementerian Pekerjaan Umum (Jakarta, 2012) 21-22, online: Dirjen Cipta Karya
Donald, Alice & Elizabeth Mottershaw. Poverty , Inequality and Human Rights: Do Human Rights Make a Difference ? (2009).
Doz Costa, Fernanda. “Poverty and Human Rights: From Rhetoric to Legal Obligations - A Critical Account of Conceptual Framework” (2008) 81:9 Sur - Int J Hum Rights 81.
Eckardt, Sebastian. “Political Accountability, Fiscal Conditions and Local Government Perfomance-Cross-sectional Evidence from Indonesia” (2008) 28:1 Public Adm Dev 1.
Fitzpatrick, Daniel, “Beyond Dualism: Land Acquisition in Indonesia” in Tim Lindsey, ed, Indonesia: Law and Society, 2nd edition, (Sydney: The Federation Press, 2008) 224.
Fellix Januardy, Alldo et al. Mereka yang Terasing: Laporan Pemenuhan Hak atas Perumahan yang Layak bagi Korban Penggusuran Paksa Jakarta yang Menghuni Rumah Susun (Jakarta: Lembaga Bantuan Hukum Jakarta, 2016).
Fellix Januardy, Alldo, Julio Castor Achmadi & Cindy Iqbalini Fortuna. Seperti Puing: Laporan Penggusuran Paksa di Wilayah DKI Jakarta Tahun 2016 (Jakarta, 2017).
Hearne, Rory & Padraic Kenna. “Using the Human Rights Based Approach" to Tackle Housing Deprivation in an Irish Urban Housing Estate” (2014) 6:1 J Hum Rights Pract 1.
Hirschl, Ran. “" Negative " Rights vs . " Positive " Entitlements : A Comparative Study of Judicial Interpretations of Rights in an Emerging Neo-Liberal Economic Order” (2000) 22:4 Hum Rights Q 1060, online:
Human Rights Watch (HRW), Condemned Communities Forced Evictions, Vol 18 No. 10C (Jakarta: HRW, 2006) online: HRW < Human Rights Watch, “Condemned Communities Forced Evictions>.
“Indonesia to strive for poverty rate below 10 percent”, Jakarta Post (4 January 2018) online: The Jakarta Post < http://www.thejakartapost.com>.
Jones, Paul. “Formalizing the informal: Understanding the position of informal settlements and slums in sustainable urbanization policies and strategies in Bandung, Indonesia” (2017) 9 Sustainability.
Jonsson, Urban. Human Rights Approach to Development Programming (UNICEF, 2003).
Kusumawati, Erna Dyah. “Between Public and Communal Interests: a Legality Issue of Forced Evictions Occurring in Jakarta” (2018) 8:1 Indones Law Rev 87.
Kusumawati, Erna Dyah, The Recurring Dream of Affordable Housing in Indonesia: A Human Rights Perspective in Michel Vols & Sidoli, J. (eds.), People and Buildings: Comparative Housing Law. Studies in Housing law Vol. 2 (The Hague: Eleven International Publisher) 105-140;
Kusumawati, Erna Dyah, De wolf, Antenor H. & Brus, M.M.T.A, “Access to Public Housing for Outsiders; a Practice of Indirect Discrimination in Decentralised Indonesia” (Forthcoming) APJHRL.
McNeill, Desmond & Asuncion Lera St Clair. “Poverty, Human Rights, and Global Justice: The Response-Ability of Multilateral Organizations” (2011) 8:1 Globalizations 97, online:
Minnery, John et al. “Slum upgrading and urban governance: Case studies in three South East Asian cities” (2013) 39 Habitat Int 162, online:
OHCHR, Human Rights Dimension of Poverty, online: OHCHR
OHCHR, Frequently Asked Questions on a Human Rights-Based Approach to Development Cooperation, HR/PUB/06/8, 2006, at 16-18, online: OHCHR
Ploeg, Lidewij van der & Frank Vanclay. “A human rights based approach to project induced displacement and resettlement” (2017) 35:1 Impact Assess Proj Apprais 34, online:
Pogge, Thomas. “Severe Poverty as a Human Rights Violation” in Thomas Pogge, ed, Free from Poverty as a Human Right who owes what to very poor? (Oxford: UNESCO and Oxford University Press, 2007) 11.
Potts, Hellen. “Accountability and the Right to Highest Attainable Standard of Health” in Paul Hunt and Tony Gray, eds, Maternal Morality, Human Rights and Accountability (New York: Routledge, 2013) 121.
Potts, Helen. Accountability and the Right to the Highest Attainable Standard of Health. (Essex, 2007).
R Osmani, Siddiq. “The Human Rights-based Approach to Development in the Era of Globalization” in OHCHR, ed, Realiz right to Dev Essays Commem 25 Years United Nations Declar Right to Dev (New York: United Nations, 2013) 117.
Reerink, Gustaaf & Jean Louis van Gelder. “Land titling, perceived tenure security, and housing consolidation in the kampongs of Bandung, Indonesia” (2010) 34:1 Habitat Int 78, online:
Sen, Amartya. “Concepts of Poverty” in Poverty Famines An Essay Entitlement (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1983) 1.
Stapenhurst, Rick and Mitchell O’Brien, Accountability in Governance, online: World Bank Publication
Suryahadi, Asep, Gracia Hadiwidjaja & Sudarno Sumarto. “Economic Growth and Poverty Reduction in Indonesia Before and After the Asian Financial Crisis” (2012) 48:2 Bull Indones Econ Stud 209.
Sutari, Tiara. “Warga Rusun Akui Tunggak Sewa Karena Kesulitan Ekonomi”, CNN Indonesia (6 September 2017) online: CNN Indonesia
Terminski, Bogumil. Development-Induces Displacement and Resettlement: Causes, Consequences and Socio Legal Context (Stuttgart: Ibidem, 2015).
The Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights (OHCHR), Human Rights and Poverty Reduction: A Conceptual Framework, (Geneva, New York: United Nations, 2004) online: OHCHR < https://www.ohchr.org/Documents/Publications/PovertyReductionen.pdf>.
Tunas, Devisari & Andrea Peresthu. “The self-help housing in Indonesia: The only option for the poor?” (2010) 34:3 Habitat Int 315, online:
Vandenhole, Wouter & Paul Gready. “Failures and Successes of Human Rights-Based Approaches to Development: Towards a Change Perspective” (2014) 32:4 Nord J Hum Rights 291, online:
Voorst, Roanne Van. “Applying the risk society thesis within the context of flood risk and poverty in Jakarta, Indonesia” (2015) 17:3–4 Heal Risk Soc 246.
Sen, Amartya. “Concepts of Poverty” in Poverty Famines An Essay Entitlement (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1983).
Shue, Henry. Basic Rights: Subsistence, Affluence, and U.S. Foreign Policy, 2nd ed (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1996).
Suryahadi, Asep et al. Review of Government’s Poverty Reduction Strategies, Policies, and Programs in Indonesia (Jakarta, 2010).
United Nations Development Program (UNDP), Human Development Report 2000: Human Rights and Human Development, (New York: Oxford University Press & UNDP, 2000).
Wetterberg, Anna, Jana C. Hertz, & Derick W. Brinkerhoff,” Social Accountability in Frontline Service Delivery: Citizen Empowerment and State Response in Four Indonesian Districts” in the International Development Group Working Paper Series (New York: the RTI International, 2015).
E. General Websites
The UN Habitat website