Old Wine in a New Bottle

Neoliberalism and Water Resources Law 2019 in Indonesia

  • Imam Koeswahyono Faculty of Law, Brawijaya University, Indonesia
  • Syahriza Alkohir Anggoro Faculty of Law, Brawijaya University, Indonesia
  • Muhammad Dahlan Faculty of Law, Brawijaya University, Indonesia

Abstract

Resistance to neoliberal legal reforms has increased globally in recent decades due to the failure of water privatization to ensure affordable and sustainable water access in the global South. Referring to the 2004 and 2019 Water Resources Laws, this paper explores how, in the case of Indonesia, the law reproduces and normalizes neoliberal ideologies that frame water as an economic commodity. We argue that Indonesia's current legal regime governing water resources is based on populist rhetoric of fulfilling the human right to water through state management. However, the adopted water governance regime aims to facilitate the establishment of a climate conducive to private sector investment by shifting responsibility for the fulfillment of the human right to water from the state to a market-based allocation system. This paper examines the strategy adopted by the government in securing the water privatization agenda when dealing with judicial activism that requires water to be managed as a public good.

References

ADB, Indonesia Country Water Assessment, by ADB (Manila: Asian Development Bank, 2016).

Adityo, Eko, “Swasta Masih Dibutuhkan Sediakan Air Bersih”, beritasatu.com (21 December 2017), online: .

Al ’Afghani, Mohamad Mova, “Anti?Privatisation Debates, Opaque Rules and ‘Privatised’ Water Services Provision: Some Lessons from Indonesia” (2012) 43:2 IDS Bull 21–26.

Al’Afghani, Mohamad Mova, “Alienating the ‘Private’ Sector: Implications of the Invalidation of the Water Law by the Indonesian Constitutional Court” (2019) 26:3 J Water Law 1–24.

———, “Constitutional Court’s Review and the Future of Water Law in Indonesia” (2006) 2:1 Law Environ Dev LEAD J 2006 1–18.

———, “Hak atas Air dalam Konteks Privatisasi dan Korporatisasi”, (15 March 2021), online: investor.id .

———, “Open Government Improves Water Services”, (6 August 2018), online: .

Alaidrus, Fadiyah, “PAM Jaya: Temuan Kerugian Rp1,2 Triliun Saat Aset Dikelola Swasta”, tirto.id (2019), online: .

Anggoro, Syahriza Alkohir, Reformasi Pasar Dan Perubahan Konstitusi Ekonomi Di Indonesia Pasca Orde Baru (Magister, Brawijaya University, 2019) [unpublished].

Ardhanie, Nila, “What next after the water law annulled”, Jkt Post (3 March 2015), online: .

Ardhianie, Nila, “Water Privatization in Indonesia” in Belen Balanya, ed, Reclaiming Public Water Achiev Struggl Vis World (Amsterdam: TNI, 2005) 227.

Assegaf, Ibrahim Sjarief, Kanya Satwika & Aisyah Siregar, “Wading Through Indonesia’s New Water Resources Law” (2019) Assegaf Hamzah Partn, online: .

Bakker, Karen, “Neoliberalizing Nature? Market Environmentalism in Water Supply in England and Wales” (2005) 95:3 Ann Assoc Am Geogr 542–565.

———, Privatizing Water: Governance Failure and the World’s Urban Water Crisis (New York: Cornell University Press, 2010).

———, “The ‘Commons’ Versus the ‘Commodity’: Alter-globalization, Anti-privatization and the Human Right to Water in the Global South” (2007) 39:3 Antipode 430–455.

Bappenas, Rancangan Teknokratik Rencana Pembangunan Jangka Menengah Nasional 2020–2024, Jakarta, Bappenas., by Bappenas (Jakarta: Bappenas, 2020).

betahitaid, “Kedok Investasi dalam Pengesahan RUU Sumber Daya Air”, (20 September 2019), online: .
Boelens, Rutgerd & Margreet Zwarteveen, “Prices and Politics in Andean Water Reforms” (2005) 36:4 Dev Change 736–758.

BPPSPAM, Buku Kinerja BUMD Penyelenggara SPAM 2019, by BPPSPAM (Jakarta: BPPSPAM, 2019).

———, Model Pembiayaan melalui Kontrak Berbayar Angsuran, by BPPSPAM (2019).

Braadbaart, Okke, “Privatizing Water The Jakarta Concession and the Limits of Contract” in Peter Boomgaard, ed, World Water Rain Rivers Seas Southeast Asian Hist (Leiden: KITLV Press, 2007) 297.

Brabazon, Honor, “Introduction: Understanding Neoliberal Legality” in Honor Brabazon, ed, Neoliberal Leg Underst Role Law Neoliberal Proj (Routledge, 2017).

Bruff, Ian, “The Rise of Authoritarian Neoliberalism” (2014) 26:1 Rethink Marx J Econ Cult Soc 113–129.

Butt, Simon & Tim Lindsey, “Economic Reform When the Constitution Matters: Indonesia’s Constitutional Court and Article 33” (2008) 44:2 Bull Indones Econ Stud 239–262.

———,The Constitution of Indonesia: A Contextual Analysis (Oxford: Hart Publishing, 2012).

Butt, Simon, The Constitutional Court and Democracy in Indonesia (Leiden: BRILL, 2015).

Cheow, Eric Teo Chu, “Privatization of Water Services via Public-Private Partnership and Implications for Southeast Asia” in Poh Onn Lee, ed, Water Issues Southeast Asia Present Trends Future Dir (Singapore: ISEAS–Yusof Ishak Institute, 2012) 76.

Clark, Cristy, “Of What Use is a Deradicalized Human Right to Water?” (2017) 17:2 Hum Rights Law Rev 231–260.

———, “Water justice struggles as a process of commoning” (2019) 54:1 Community Dev J 80–99.

Colbran, Nicola, “Piped Water in Jakarta: A Political, Economic or Social Good?” in Anna F S Russell & Malcolm Langford, eds, Hum Right Water Theory Pract Prospects (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2017) 463.

Facal, Gabriel & Gloria Truly Estrelita, “Social Movements Facing Authoritarian-Style Neoliberal Governments: Comparative Positioning Towards Violence in Indonesia and France” (2020) 32:3 Humaniora 226–239.

Franco, Jennifer, Lyla Mehta & Gert Jan Veldwisch, “The Global Politics of Water Grabbing” (2013) 34:9 Third World Q 1651–1675.

Frianan, Hendra, “RUU SDA: Dinilai Bakal Hambat Investasi & Tak Sesuai Visi Jokowi”, (31 July 2019), online: tirto.id .

Friends of the Earth International, Water Justice for All Global and Local Resistance to the Control and Commodification of Water, by Friends of the Earth International (Amsterdam: Friend of the Earth International Secretariat, 2003).

Fukuoka, Yuki & Luky Djani, “Revisiting the rise of Jokowi: The triumph of reformasi or an oligarchic adaptation of post-clientelist initiatives?” (2016) 24:2 South East Asia Res 204–221.

Furlong, Kathryn et al, “Rethinking water corporatisation: A ‘negotiation space’ for public and private interests, Colombia (1910-2000)” (2018) 11:1 Water Altern 187–208.

Hadipuro, Wijanto & Prathiwi Widyatmi Putri, “Right-to-water Alliances in Indonesia and Two Critical Disjunctions” (2020) 8:1 Power Confl Democr 29–47.

Hadipuro, Wijanto, “Indonesia’s Water Supply Regulatory Framework: Between Commercialisation and Public Service?” (2010) 3:3 Water Altern 475–491.

Hendrianto, Stefanus, “The Divergence of a Wandering Court: Socio-Economic Rights in the Indonesian Constitutional Court” (2016) 16:2 Aust J Asian Law 1–21.

Herliana, Backlash Against Foreign Investment Regime: Indonesia’s Experience (PhD Dissertation, University of Washington, 2017) [unpublished].

Hukumonline, “Walhi Minta Kejelasan MK Soal Putusan UU SDA”, (22 June 2005), online: Hukumonline.com.

Jakarta Globe, “Editorial: Revoking Water Law Is a Washed-Up Move”, (26 February 2015), online: Jakartaglobe.id.

Jensen, Olivia, “Public-Private Partnership for Water in Asia: A Review of two Decades of Experience” (2017) 33:1 Int J Water Resour Dev 4–30.

Kadir, MYa’kub Aiyub & Alexander Murray, “Resource Nationalism in the Law and Policies of Indonesia: A Contest of State, Foreign Investors, and Indigenous Peoples” (2019) 9 Asian J Int Law 298–333.

Kivilcim, Zeynep, “Articulating Human Rights Discourse in Local Struggles in a Neoliberal Age” in Ben Golder & Daniel McLoughlin, eds, Polit Leg Neoliberal Age (New York: Routlege, 2018).

KruHa, “Air Ada Dimana-mana, Tapi Terlalu Mahal untuk Dijangkau”, (2021), online: kruha.org .

LBH Jakarta, Catatan Akhir Tahun 2019 Reformasi Dikorupsi Demokrasi Direpresi, by LBH Jakarta (Jakarta: LBH Jakarta, 2019).

Li, Tania Murray, “Commons, Co-ops, and Corporations: Assembling Indonesia’s Twenty-First Century Land Reform” (2021) 48:3 J Peasant Stud 613–639.

Lobina, Emanuele, Vera Weghmann & Marwa Marwa, “Water Justice Will Not Be Televised: Moral Advocacy and the Struggle for Transformative Remunicipalisation in Jakarta” (2019) 12 Water Altern 725–748.

Loftus, Alex & Jessica Budds, “Neoliberalizing Water” in Simon Springer, Kean Birch & Julie MacLeavy, eds, Handb Neoliberalism (New York: Routledge, 2016) 503.

MediaIndonesia, “Digodok, PP Pengelolaan Air”, (27 February 2015), online: Mediaindonesia.com.

Mercille, Julien & Enda Murphy, “What is Privatization? A Political Economy Framework” (2017) 49:5 Environ Plan 1040–1059.

Merdekacom, “Menteri Basuki: Swasta Boleh Kelola Sumber Daya Air, tapi Kepemilikan Tetap Negara”, (1 August 2019).

Mufti, Riza Roidila, “House Accommodates Business Aspirations in New Water Law”, (2019), online: .

Muhtadi, Burhanuddin, “Jokowi’s First Year: A Weak President Caught between Reform and Oligarchic Politics” (2015) 51:3 Bull Indones Econ Stud 349–368.

Nurshafira, Tadzkia, “Swasta, Negara, dan Hak atas Air”, (2019), online: .

Omara, Andy, Protecting Economic and Social Rights in a Constitutionally Strong Form of Judicial Review: the Case of Constitutional Review by Indonesian Constitutional Court (PhD dissertation, University of Washington, 2017) [unpublished].

Pebrianto, Fajar, “UU Sumber Daya Air Kembali Digugat ke Mahkamah Konstitusi”, (14 January 2021), online: .

Pompe, Sebastiaan, The Indonesian Supreme Court, A Study of Institutional Collapse, by Sebastiaan Pompe (Ithaca: Cornell Southeast Asia Program, 2005).

Power, Thomas, “Jokowi’s Authoritarian Turn and Indonesia’s Democratic Decline” (2018) 54:3 Bull Indones Econ Stud 307–338.

PT Cekindo Business International, “Where to Invest: Water Treatment Sector in Indonesia”, (20 April 2021), online: Cekindo .

PwC, Indonesian Infrastructure Stable Foundations for Growth, by PwC (Jakarta: PwC, 2016).

Ray, David & Lili Yan Ing, “Addressing Indonesia’s Infrastructure Deficit” (2016) 52:1 Bull Indones Econ Stud 1–25.

Robison, Richard, Indonesia:The Rise of Capital, Sydney (Sydney: Allen & Unwin, 1986).

Romero, Maria Jose, History RePPPeated How Public Private Partnership are Failing, by Maria Jose Romero (Heinrich-Böll-Stiftung, 2018).

Salim, Tama, “Govt to Draft Rules to Fill Void in Water Management”, Jkt Post (2015), online: .

Shidarta & Stijn Cornelis van Huis, “Between Revenues and Public Service Delivery SOEs and PSAS in Indonesia” (2020) 176:202 Bijdr Tot Taal- Land- En Volkenkd J Humanit Soc Sci Southeast Asia Ocean 304–337.

Stockmann, Petra, The New Indonesian Constitutional Court A Study into Its Beginnings and First Years of Work (Jakarta: Hanns Siedel Foundation, 2007).

Susanti, Bivitri, Neo-liberalism and Its Resistance in Indonesia’s Constitution Reform 1999–2002: A Constitutional and Historical Review of Indonesian Socialism and Neo-liberalism (Dissertation Master of Law, University of Warwick, 2002) [unpublished].

Talan, John Petrus et al, Tak Ada Rakyat dalam Omnibus Law/RUU Cipta Kerja Sebuah Kertas Kerja, by John Petrus Talan et al (Jakarta: Koalisi Rakyat untuk Hak atas Air, 2020).

Tansel, Cemal Burak, “Reproducing Authoritarian Neoliberalism in Turkey: Urban Governance and State Restructuring in the Shadow of Executive Centralization” (2018) 16:3 Globalizations 320–335.

Tempo, “Expert: Water Tariff in Jakarta Highest in South East Asia”, Tempo.com (11 January 2015).

Truswell, Emma, “Thirst for Profit: Water Privatization, Investment Law and a Human Right to Water” in Chester Brown & Kate Miles, eds, Evol Invest Treaty Law Arbitr (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2011) 570.

UNESCO, The United Nations World Water Development Report 2020 Water and Climate Change, by UNESCO (Paris: United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cutural Organization, 2020).

Uruena, Rene, “Global Water Governance and the Rise of Constitutional Regulatory State in Colombia” in Navroz Dubash & Bronwen Morgan, eds, Rise Regul State South (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2013) 27.

Venning, Philippa, “Determination of Economic, Social and Cultural Rights by the Indonesian Constitutional Court” (2008) 10:1 Aust J Asian Law 100–132.

Walhi, Tinjauan Lingkungan Hidup 2020 Menabur Investasi Menuai Krisis Multidimensi, by Walhi (Jakarta: Walhi, 2020).

Warburton, Eve, “Jokowi and New Developmentalism” (2016) 52:3 Bull Indones Econ Stud 297–320.

Wijaya, Trissia & Alvin Camba, “The politics of public–private partnerships: state–capital relations and spatial fixes in Indonesia and the Philippines” (2021) Territ Polit Gov 1–21.

World Bank, Water Supply and Sanitation in Indonesia Turning Finance into Service for the Future, by World Bank (Washington D.C: World Bank, 2015).

Wulansari, Husna Yuni & Tadzkia Nurshafira, “In Indonesia, Water can be a Public and Private Good”, (2019), online: .
Published
2022-06-29
How to Cite
KOESWAHYONO, Imam; ANGGORO, Syahriza Alkohir; DAHLAN, Muhammad. Old Wine in a New Bottle. Journal of Southeast Asian Human Rights, [S.l.], v. 6, n. 1, p. 26-54, june 2022. ISSN 2599-2147. Available at: <https://jurnal.unej.ac.id/index.php/JSEAHR/article/view/29084>. Date accessed: 27 sep. 2022. doi: https://doi.org/10.19184/jseahr.v6i1.29084.
Section
Articles

Most read articles by the same author(s)

Obs.: This plugin requires at least one statistics/report plugin to be enabled. If your statistics plugins provide more than one metric then please also select a main metric on the admin's site settings page and/or on the journal manager's settings pages.