Reformulation of Agrarian Regulations Within a Human Rights Framework
Abstract
The complexities of land and natural resource cases involve multiple stakeholders ranging from the government and security forces to corporations. The conflicts that drive these cases are reflected in the Indonesian Commission on Human Rights data and in complaints from civil society. One contributing issue is driven by regulatory factors in the agrarian sector that is not in line with international human rights principles and norms. The analysis of these problems will be described in three discussions: one identifying the meaning of agrarian followed by a model for internalizing human rights instruments and principles in domestic regulations, and one affirming the responsibilities of the State and of corporations in the business. This paper concludes that differences in agrarian terms in various laws cause problems in norms and practices that affect multiple conflicts. Second, it emphasizes the urgency with which key players must evaluate different sectoral rules related to land and natural resources as well as harmonize domestic regulations with human rights principles and norms; and third, it underscores the importance of strengthening the responsibility of the State in regulating corporations to respect human rights and to make remedies for victims.
Keywords: land and natural resources, agrarian reform, human rights instruments and principles, state and corporate responsibility
References
Agestyaning, Mahardika, Public Input in the Preparation of Regulatory Standards and Norms on Land and Natural Resources, by Mahardika Agestyaning (Jakarta, 2021).
Agrarian Reform Consortium, The Covid-19 Pandemic, and Large-Scale Land Seizure, by Agrarian Reform Consortium (Jakarta, 2020).
Asshiddiqie, Jimly, “The idea of the Indonesian rule of law” (2011) 25 BPHN 1–17.
Ballard, Chris, “Human Rights and the Mining Sector in Indonesia : A Baseline Study” (2002) 182 Mining, Miner Sustain Dev 53.
BF Sihombing, Edy Lisdiyono, “Agrarian Reform in Indonesia: A Juridical Review” (2012) 8:11 Int J Civ Eng Technol 248–356, online:.
Binnie, Ian, “Legal Remedies for Corporate Participation in International Human Rights Abuses” (2009) 38:4 Br Chicago 44–51.
Bonnitcha, Jonathan & Robert McCorquodale, "The concept of 'due diligence in the UN Guiding Principles on business and Human Rights" (2017) 28:3 Eur J Int Law 899–919.
Campos, Andre Santos, “Intergenerational Justice Today” (2018) 13:3 Philos Compass 1–23.
Candra, Sapto Andika, “Meet Jokowi, Komnas HAM Conveys Agrarian Conflict”, online: republika.co.id.
Commission, European Commission Staff Working Document on Implementing the UN Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights - State of Play, by European Commission (2015).
Commissioner, United Nations Human Rights Office of The High, Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights, by United Nations Human Rights Office of The High Commissioner, A/HRC/17/31 (New York and Geneva, 2011).
Fahmi, Chairul & Muhammad Siddiq Armia, “Protecting Indigenous Collective Land Property in Indonesia under International Human Rights Norms” (2022) 6:1 J Southeast Asian Hum Rights 1–25.
Felice, Damiano de, “Business and human rights indicators to measure the corporate responsibility to respect: Challenges and opportunities” (2015) 37:2 Hum Rights Q 511–555.
Fian International, Maastricht Principles on Extraterritorial Obligations of States in the Area of Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, by Fian International (Heidelberg, Germany, 2013).
Fitzpatrick, Daniel, “Dispute and Plularism in Modern Indonesian Land Law” (1997) 22:1 Yale J Int Law 171–212.
Guidance Note of the Secretary-General: the United Nations and Land and Conflict, 2019.
Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights, Guide Princ Bus Hum rights 2011.
Hansén, Nora, The Human Right to Water and its Status in International Law Stockholm University, 2018) [unpublished].
Ibhawoh, Bonny, “The Right to Development: The Politics and Polemics of Power and Resistance” (2011) 33:1 Hum Rights Q 76–104.
Joseph, Sarah, Research Handbook on International Human Rights Law (USA: Edward Elgar (EE), 2010).
Keraf, Sonny, Input Standard Norms and Regulations on Land and Natural Resources, by Sonny Keraf (Jakarta, 2021).
Kinley, David, Justine Nolan & Natalie Zerial, "The politics of corporate social responsibility: reflections on the United Nations Human Rights Norms for Corporation" (2007) 30:December 2006 Co Secure Law J 30–42.
Koenig-Archibugi, Mathias, “Transnational Corporations and Public Accountability” (2004) 39:2 Gov Oppos 234–259.
Komnas HAM and Elsam, National Action Plan for Business and Human Rights, Komnas HAM and Elsam (Jakarta, 2017).
Lehavi, Amnon, “The Universal Law of the Land” (2011) SSRN Electron J 1–32.
Marks, Stephen, “The Human Right to Development: Between Rhetoric and Reality” (2004) 17:1988 Harv Hum Rights J 137–168.
Meyer, William H, “Human Rights and MNCs : Theory Versus Quantitative Analysis” (1996) 18:2 Hum Rights Q 368–397.
Mujiburohman, Dian Aries, “Legalzation of Former Eighendom Rights Land” (2021) 14:1 Yudisial 117–137.
Mzikenge Chirwa, Danwood, “The Doctrine of State Responsibility as a Potential Means of Holding Private Actors Accountable for Human Rights’ (2004) 5(1) Melbourne Journal of International Law 1 MLA 9th ed. Chirwa, Danwood Mzikenge” (2004) 1:1 Melb J Int Law 1–36, online:.
Nasir, Mohamad, “The Implication of Law No. 11 of 2020 concerning Job Creation towards Regulation on the Permit to Open Land State in East Kalimantan” (2021) 17:2 J Borneo Adm 155–168.
OCHCR, Land and Human Rights Standards and Applications (Geneva, 2015).
Olly, G Abrielle H, “Transnational Tort and Access to Remedy under the UN Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights: Kamasaee v. Commonwealth” (2018) 19:1 Melb J Int Law 2–31.
Pausenberger, Ehrenfried, “How Powerful are the Multinational Corporations ?” (1983) 18:3 INTERECONOMIC 130–136, online:.
Rachman, Noer Fauzi, The Resurgence of Land Reform Policy and Agrarian Movements in Indonesia University of California, Berkeley Committee, 2011) [unpublished].
Sahari, Alpi, “Legal Protection in the Use of Land for Mining Activities” (2022) 3:3 Randwick Int Soc Sci J 591–597.
Scheinin, Martin, Report of The Special Rapporteur on the Promotion and Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms while Countering Terrorism, by Martin Scheinin (2010).
Shrestha, Raj K & Rattan Lal, “Geoderma Changes in physical and chemical properties of soil after surface mining and reclamation” (2021) 161:3–4 Geoderma 168–176.
Simarmata, Henry Thomas, The principle of non-discrimination and intergenerational justice in the land and natural resources, by Henry Thomas Simarmata, FGD Norm and Standard (Jakarta, 2021).
Sirait, Martua; Chif Fay, Kerangka Hukum Negara dalam Mengatur Agraria dan Kehutanan : Mempertanyakan Sistem Ganda Kewenangan atas Pengusaan Tanah, by Martua; Chif Fay Sirait, ICRAF Southeast Asia Working Paper (Jakarta, 2004).
Springer, Jenny, Jessica Campese & Michael Painter, Conservation and Human Rights: Key Issues and Contexts (OCHCR, 2011).
Standards and Regulation Number 7 about Human Rights to Land and Natural Resources, 2021.
Suntoro, Agus, Application of Humanitarian Principles in the Study of Legislation, by Agus Suntoro (Jakarta, 2019).
Suryadi, M et al., "The agricultural land distribution and used on various agroecosystems in Indonesia" (2021) 892:1 IOP Conf Ser Earth Environ Sci 1–8.
Suryasaputra, Saafroedin Bahar; Ruswiati, "Direction of National Law Politics towards Legal Protection for Indigenous Peoples Based on the Unitary State of the Republic of Indonesia" (2012) 8:4 J HAM 1–28, online:.
The Indonesian Commission on Human Right, Komnas HAM complaint case issue, by The Indonesian Commission on Human Right (Jakarta, 2021).
———, Komnas HAM Strategic Plan 2020-2024, by The Indonesian Commission on Human Right (Jakarta, 2020).
———, Performance Accountability Report of the Bureau of Human Rights Enforcement, by The Indonesian Commission on Human Right (Jakarta, 2018).
Tremmel, Joerg Chet, “Handbook of Intergenerational Justice” in Edward Elgar Publ Ltd (Massachusetts, USA: Edward Elgar Publishing, Inc, 2006) 1.
United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Peasants and Other People Working in Rural Areas, Seventy-third Sess Resolute Adopt by Gen Assem December 17, 2018.
Vienna Declaration and Programme of Action, 1993.
Wettstein, Florian, “Normativity, Ethics, and the UN Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights: A Critical Assessment” (2015) 14:2 J Hum Rights 162–182.
Agrarian Reform Consortium, The Covid-19 Pandemic, and Large-Scale Land Seizure, by Agrarian Reform Consortium (Jakarta, 2020).
Asshiddiqie, Jimly, “The idea of the Indonesian rule of law” (2011) 25 BPHN 1–17.
Ballard, Chris, “Human Rights and the Mining Sector in Indonesia : A Baseline Study” (2002) 182 Mining, Miner Sustain Dev 53.
BF Sihombing, Edy Lisdiyono, “Agrarian Reform in Indonesia: A Juridical Review” (2012) 8:11 Int J Civ Eng Technol 248–356, online:
Binnie, Ian, “Legal Remedies for Corporate Participation in International Human Rights Abuses” (2009) 38:4 Br Chicago 44–51.
Bonnitcha, Jonathan & Robert McCorquodale, "The concept of 'due diligence in the UN Guiding Principles on business and Human Rights" (2017) 28:3 Eur J Int Law 899–919.
Campos, Andre Santos, “Intergenerational Justice Today” (2018) 13:3 Philos Compass 1–23.
Candra, Sapto Andika, “Meet Jokowi, Komnas HAM Conveys Agrarian Conflict”, online: republika.co.id
Commission, European Commission Staff Working Document on Implementing the UN Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights - State of Play, by European Commission (2015).
Commissioner, United Nations Human Rights Office of The High, Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights, by United Nations Human Rights Office of The High Commissioner, A/HRC/17/31 (New York and Geneva, 2011).
Fahmi, Chairul & Muhammad Siddiq Armia, “Protecting Indigenous Collective Land Property in Indonesia under International Human Rights Norms” (2022) 6:1 J Southeast Asian Hum Rights 1–25.
Felice, Damiano de, “Business and human rights indicators to measure the corporate responsibility to respect: Challenges and opportunities” (2015) 37:2 Hum Rights Q 511–555.
Fian International, Maastricht Principles on Extraterritorial Obligations of States in the Area of Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, by Fian International (Heidelberg, Germany, 2013).
Fitzpatrick, Daniel, “Dispute and Plularism in Modern Indonesian Land Law” (1997) 22:1 Yale J Int Law 171–212.
Guidance Note of the Secretary-General: the United Nations and Land and Conflict, 2019.
Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights, Guide Princ Bus Hum rights 2011.
Hansén, Nora, The Human Right to Water and its Status in International Law Stockholm University, 2018) [unpublished].
Ibhawoh, Bonny, “The Right to Development: The Politics and Polemics of Power and Resistance” (2011) 33:1 Hum Rights Q 76–104.
Joseph, Sarah, Research Handbook on International Human Rights Law (USA: Edward Elgar (EE), 2010).
Keraf, Sonny, Input Standard Norms and Regulations on Land and Natural Resources, by Sonny Keraf (Jakarta, 2021).
Kinley, David, Justine Nolan & Natalie Zerial, "The politics of corporate social responsibility: reflections on the United Nations Human Rights Norms for Corporation" (2007) 30:December 2006 Co Secure Law J 30–42.
Koenig-Archibugi, Mathias, “Transnational Corporations and Public Accountability” (2004) 39:2 Gov Oppos 234–259.
Komnas HAM and Elsam, National Action Plan for Business and Human Rights, Komnas HAM and Elsam (Jakarta, 2017).
Lehavi, Amnon, “The Universal Law of the Land” (2011) SSRN Electron J 1–32.
Marks, Stephen, “The Human Right to Development: Between Rhetoric and Reality” (2004) 17:1988 Harv Hum Rights J 137–168.
Meyer, William H, “Human Rights and MNCs : Theory Versus Quantitative Analysis” (1996) 18:2 Hum Rights Q 368–397.
Mujiburohman, Dian Aries, “Legalzation of Former Eighendom Rights Land” (2021) 14:1 Yudisial 117–137.
Mzikenge Chirwa, Danwood, “The Doctrine of State Responsibility as a Potential Means of Holding Private Actors Accountable for Human Rights’ (2004) 5(1) Melbourne Journal of International Law 1 MLA 9th ed. Chirwa, Danwood Mzikenge” (2004) 1:1 Melb J Int Law 1–36, online:
Nasir, Mohamad, “The Implication of Law No. 11 of 2020 concerning Job Creation towards Regulation on the Permit to Open Land State in East Kalimantan” (2021) 17:2 J Borneo Adm 155–168.
OCHCR, Land and Human Rights Standards and Applications (Geneva, 2015).
Olly, G Abrielle H, “Transnational Tort and Access to Remedy under the UN Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights: Kamasaee v. Commonwealth” (2018) 19:1 Melb J Int Law 2–31.
Pausenberger, Ehrenfried, “How Powerful are the Multinational Corporations ?” (1983) 18:3 INTERECONOMIC 130–136, online:
Rachman, Noer Fauzi, The Resurgence of Land Reform Policy and Agrarian Movements in Indonesia University of California, Berkeley Committee, 2011) [unpublished].
Sahari, Alpi, “Legal Protection in the Use of Land for Mining Activities” (2022) 3:3 Randwick Int Soc Sci J 591–597.
Scheinin, Martin, Report of The Special Rapporteur on the Promotion and Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms while Countering Terrorism, by Martin Scheinin (2010).
Shrestha, Raj K & Rattan Lal, “Geoderma Changes in physical and chemical properties of soil after surface mining and reclamation” (2021) 161:3–4 Geoderma 168–176.
Simarmata, Henry Thomas, The principle of non-discrimination and intergenerational justice in the land and natural resources, by Henry Thomas Simarmata, FGD Norm and Standard (Jakarta, 2021).
Sirait, Martua; Chif Fay, Kerangka Hukum Negara dalam Mengatur Agraria dan Kehutanan : Mempertanyakan Sistem Ganda Kewenangan atas Pengusaan Tanah, by Martua; Chif Fay Sirait, ICRAF Southeast Asia Working Paper (Jakarta, 2004).
Springer, Jenny, Jessica Campese & Michael Painter, Conservation and Human Rights: Key Issues and Contexts (OCHCR, 2011).
Standards and Regulation Number 7 about Human Rights to Land and Natural Resources, 2021.
Suntoro, Agus, Application of Humanitarian Principles in the Study of Legislation, by Agus Suntoro (Jakarta, 2019).
Suryadi, M et al., "The agricultural land distribution and used on various agroecosystems in Indonesia" (2021) 892:1 IOP Conf Ser Earth Environ Sci 1–8.
Suryasaputra, Saafroedin Bahar; Ruswiati, "Direction of National Law Politics towards Legal Protection for Indigenous Peoples Based on the Unitary State of the Republic of Indonesia" (2012) 8:4 J HAM 1–28, online:
The Indonesian Commission on Human Right, Komnas HAM complaint case issue, by The Indonesian Commission on Human Right (Jakarta, 2021).
———, Komnas HAM Strategic Plan 2020-2024, by The Indonesian Commission on Human Right (Jakarta, 2020).
———, Performance Accountability Report of the Bureau of Human Rights Enforcement, by The Indonesian Commission on Human Right (Jakarta, 2018).
Tremmel, Joerg Chet, “Handbook of Intergenerational Justice” in Edward Elgar Publ Ltd (Massachusetts, USA: Edward Elgar Publishing, Inc, 2006) 1.
United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Peasants and Other People Working in Rural Areas, Seventy-third Sess Resolute Adopt by Gen Assem December 17, 2018.
Vienna Declaration and Programme of Action, 1993.
Wettstein, Florian, “Normativity, Ethics, and the UN Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights: A Critical Assessment” (2015) 14:2 J Hum Rights 162–182.
Published
2022-12-30
How to Cite
SUNTORO, Agus; UTOMO, Nurrahman Aji; HERMANTO, Mardhika Agestyaning.
Reformulation of Agrarian Regulations Within a Human Rights Framework.
Journal of Southeast Asian Human Rights, [S.l.], v. 6, n. 2, p. 131-152, dec. 2022.
ISSN 2599-2147.
Available at: <https://jurnal.unej.ac.id/index.php/JSEAHR/article/view/27776>. Date accessed: 22 dec. 2024.
doi: https://doi.org/10.19184/jseahr.v6i2.27776.
Section
Articles
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
