Political Participation of Minors in India
A Critical Perspective from the Prism of the UNCRC
Abstract
The participation of children in a political demonstration has proven to be an enduring issue in India owing to the public agitations against the Citizenship Amendment Act and the farm laws, with the latter being withdrawn recently. Under the hegemonic liberal paradigm, the underlying risk is that civil and political rights may be envisaged as the exclusive domain of adults. Children are merely viewed as apprentice citizens who do not have the capacity to exercise rational choice. The operative presumption is located in a binary wherein children are pliant beneficiaries, and the state is a benign caretaker in charge of determining their best interests. It thereby negates children’s autonomy and reduces them to disenfranchised spectators in an adult-centric social fabric. Moreover, the protectionist approach enables the state to evade its obligation of preserving democratic spaces wherein minors can protest safely and make their voices heard. State functionaries and judicial authorities in India have also been complicit in adopting an infantilising stance. In this paper, the author makes a case for recognising the agency of children such that they can exercise their ‘autonomy’ right to political participation. This paper incorporates diverse perspectives in existing child rights literature, including those emanating from the Global South, to argue in favour of an epistemic reorientation in child rights law discourse. Moreover, the author relies upon key interpretations of UNCRC provisions made by the Committee on the Rights of the Child and argues for facilitating a participative environment where children can exercise their civil and political rights. The ‘best interests’ test should not be wielded as a sword from an adult standpoint to curtail children’s rights in the political domain.
Keywords: Children's Rights, Citizenship Act, Political Participation.
References
Ananya Tiwari, “At Tikri, many bring children to the protest”, The Indian Express (31 December 2020), online:
Anter, Andreas, “The Modern State and Its Monopoly on Violence” in Edith Hanke, Lawrence Scaff & Sam Whimster, eds, The Oxford Handbook of Max Weber (Oxford University Press, 2020) 226.
Aoife Daly, “Demonstrating Positive Obligations: Children’s Rights and Peaceful Protest in International Law” (2013) 42:1 George Washington International Law Review 763–813.
Arce, Matías Cordero, “Towards an Emancipatory Discourse of Children’s Rights*” (2012) 20:3 The International Journal of Children’s Rights 365–421.
Asha Bajpai, Child Rights in India (Oxford University Press, 2017).
Bijan Kimiagar & Roger Hart, “Children’s Free Association and the Collective Exercise of Their Rights” in Martin D Ruck, Michele Peterson-Badali, & Michael Freeman, eds, Handbook of Children’s Rights: Global and Multidisciplinary Perspectives (Routledge, 2017) 498.
Boaventura de Sousa Santos & Bruno Sena Martins, “Conclusion” in Boaventura de Sousa Santos & Bruno Sena Martins, eds, The Pluriverse of Human Rights: The Diversity of Struggles for Dignity (Routledge, 2021) 256.
Brian Milne, Rights of the Child: 25 Years After the Adoption of the UN Convention (Springer, 2015).
Claire Breen, “Art.15: The Rights to Freedom of Association and Peaceful Assembly” in John Tobin, ed, The UN Convention on the Rights of the Child: A Commentary (Oxford University Press, 2019) 517.
Daalen, Edward van, Karl Hanson & Olga Nieuwenhuys, “Children’s Rights as Living Rights: The Case of Street Children and a new Law in Yogyakarta, Indonesia” (2016) 24:4 The International Journal of Children’s Rights 803–825.
Dar, Anandini & John Wall, “Children’s Political Representation: The Right to Make a Difference” (2011) 19:4 The International Journal of Children’s Rights 595–612.
E Kay M Tisdall, “Children and young people’s participation: A critical consideration of Article 12” in Wouter Vandenhole et al, eds, Routledge International Handbook of Children’s Rights Studies (Routledge, 2015) 185.
Fairhall, Nicola & Kevin Woods, “Children’s Views on Children’s Rights: A Systematic Literature Review” (2021) 29:4 The International Journal of Children’s Rights 835–871.
Faulkner, Elizabeth A & Conrad Nyamutata, “The Decolonisation of Children’s Rights and the Colonial Contours of the Convention on the Rights of the Child” (2020) 28:1 The International Journal of Children’s Rights 66–88.
Ferguson, Lucinda, “Not merely rights for children but children’s rights: The theory gap and the assumption of the importance of children’s rights” (2013) 21:2 The International Journal of Children’s Rights 177–208.
Gerison Lansdown, “National Human Rights Institutions for Children” in Jonathan Todres & Shani M King, eds, The Oxford Handbook of Children’s Rights Law (Oxford University Press, 2020) 495.
Henaghan, Mark, “Article 12 of the UN Convention on the Rights of Children” (2017) 25 International Journal of Children's Rights 537.
John Eekelaar & John Tobin, “Art. 3: The Best Interests of the Child” in John Tobin, ed, The UN Convention on the Rights of the Child: A Commentary (Oxford University Press, 2019) 73.
John Tobin, “Justifying Children’s Rights” (2013) 21 International Journal of Child Rights 395.
John Tobin & Aisling Parkes, “Art.13 The Right to Freedom of Expression” in John Tobin, ed, The UN Convention on the Rights of the Child: A Commentary (Oxford University Press, 2019) 435.
John Tobin & Sheila Varadan, “Art.5 The Right to Parental Direction and Guidance Consistent with a Child’s Evolving Capacities” in John Tobin, ed, The UN Convention on the Rights of the Child: A Commentary (Oxford University Press, 2019) 159.
Langlaude, Sylvie, “On How to Build a Positive Understanding of the Child’s Right to Freedom of Expression” (2010) 10:1 Human Rights Law Review 33–66.
Laura Lundy, John Tobin, & Aisling Parkes, “Art. 12: The Right to Respect for the Views of the Child” in John Tobin, ed, The UN Convention on the Rights of the Child: A Commentary Oxford Commentaries on International Law (Oxford University Press, 2019) 397.
Liebel, Manfred, “The Moscow Declaration on the Rights of the Child (1918)” (2016) 24:1 International Journal of Children's Rights 3–28.
Manfred Liebel, “Children’s Citizenship – Observed and Experienced” in Manfred Liebel et al, eds, Children’s Rights from Below: Cross-Cultural Perspectives Studies in Childhood and Youth (Palgrave Macmillan UK, 2012).
Manfred Liebel, “Economic and Labor Rights of Children” in Jonathan Todres & Shani M King, eds, The Oxford Handbook of Children’s Rights Law (Oxford University Press, 2020) 349.
Mattheis, Nikolas, “Unruly kids? Conceptualizing and defending youth disobedience” (2020) European Journal of Political Theory 1474885120918371.
McMurry, Nicholas, “The Right for Protest to Be Heard” (2019) 21 Whitehead Jourrnal of Diplomacy and International Relations 93.
Mégret, Frédéric & Philip Alston, The United Nations And Human Rights: A Critical Appraisal, 2nd ed (Oxford University Press, 2020).
Michel Foucault, Discipline & Punish: The Birth of the Prison, 2nd ed (Vintage Books, 1995).
Moosa-Mitha, Mehmoona, “A Difference-Centred Alternative to Theorization of Children’s Citizenship Rights” (2005) 9:4 Citizenship Studies 369–388.
Nishiyama, Kei, “Between protection and participation: Rethinking children’s rights to participate in protests on streets, online spaces, and schools” (2020) 19:4 Journal of Human Rights 501–517.
Paulo Freire, Pedagogy of the Oppressed (Continuum, 2000).
Perpetua Kirby & Rebecca Webb, “Taking Part, Joining In, And Being Heard?: Ethnographic Explorations of Children’s Participation” in Jonathan Todres & Shani M King, eds, The Oxford Handbook of Children’s Rights Law (477-494: Oxford University Press, 2020).
Peter N Stearns, “History of Children’s Rights” in Martin D Ruck (editor), Michele Peterson-Badali (editor) & Michael Freeman (editor), eds, Handbook of Children’s Rights: Global and Multidisciplinary Perspectives (Routledge, 2017) 3.
Rakshitt Bajpai, “Indian Supreme Court Arbitrarily Limits Children’s Right to Protest”, (28 May 2020), online: Oxford Human Rights Hub
Raman, Vasanthi, “Politics of Childhood: Perspectives from the South” (2000) 35:46 Economic and Political Weekly 4055–4064.
Rampal, Anita, “Scaffolded Participation of Children: Perspectives from India” (2008) 16:3 The International Journal of Children’s Rights 313–325.
Roger A Hart, Children’s Participation: From Tokenism to Citizenship, by Roger A Hart (UNICEF, 1992).
Sandberg, Kirsten, “The Convention on the Rights of the Child and the Vulnerability of Children” (2015) 84:2 Nordic Journal of International Law 221–247.
Svetlana Erpyleva, “Active citizens under Eighteen: minors in political protests” (2021) 24:9 Journal of Youth Studies 1215–1233.
Varadan, Sheila, “The Principle of Evolving Capacities under the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child” (2019) 27 International Journal of Children's Rights 306.
Wyness, Michael, “Children, Childhood and Political Participation: Case Studies of Young People’s Councils” (2001) 9 International Journal of Children's Rights 193.
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
