Constitutionalism and Human Rights
A Critical Analysis of the Rights of Transgender People in India
Abstract
The movement for decriminalizing homosexual relations and the human rights of the LGBT community has gained momentum in the last decade. In India, various NGOs and LGBT society have fought a long battle demanding the decriminalization of homosexuality and declaring sexual orientation as part of the fundamental right to life under Article 21 of the Indian Constitution. This paper explored the Indian legislative framework dealing with transgender people. Furthermore, it extensively covered the landmark judgments delivered by the Indian judiciary on the subject matter and highlighted that these judgments had played an essential role in uplifting the cause and protecting the fundamental rights of transgenders. Using doctrinal research as its methodology, this study showed that the Indian Constitution essentially provides a fundamental right to equality under Article 14, whereas Articles 15 and 16 outline that no one shall be discriminated on the ground of sex. Also, the Indian judiciary had decriminalized Section 377 of the Indian Penal Code, considered as part of landmark judgments that recognize transgender people as a third gender. India also enacted the Transgender Protection Act 2019 to ensure the rights of transgenders. However, this Act failed to address the issue of forced sex-reassignment surgeries, which had been imposed upon transgender people against their consent. On the other hand, while transgenders are legally protected, gaining acceptance from society is another arduous task in which transgenders have struggled to realize an all-inclusive and non-judgmental environment towards persons with different sexual orientations.
Keywords: Constitutionalism, Human Rights, Transgenders.
References
Aditya Saurabh, “Human Rights Violations of LGBTQI Community in India: Analysis” (2020) 107 All India Reporter.
Ali Badruddoja Molla, “Emerging Challenges to the Rights of the Transgender Persons in India” 105 All India Reporter.
Asad U Khan, “Gendered Justice: Constitutions, Trans-genders and Equality” (2019) 3 LUMS Law Journal.
B Kumar, “Human Rights Development and Democracy” (2011) 38:1 & 2 Indian Bar Review.
Chandreshwari Singh, “A Humanist Exposition of Rights of Transgender and the Indian Law” (2017) 44:4 Indian Bar Review.
Justice P Sathasivam, “Role of Courts in Protection of Human Rights” 99 All India Reporter.
K C Joshi, The Constitutional Law of India (Allahabad: Central Law Publications, 2016).
K D Gaur, Textbook on Indian Penal Code (Gurgaon: Universal Law Publications, 2016).
Lucas Ramon Mendos et al., State-Sponsored Homophobia 2020: Global Legislation Overview Update (Geneva: ILGA World, 2020).
M Michelraj, “Historical Evolution of Transgender Community in India” (2015) 4:1 Asian Review of Social Sciences.
Mamta Srivastav, “Concept and Development of Human Rights” (2015) 102 All India Reporter.
M P Jain, Indian Constitutional Law (Gurgaon: Lexis Nexis, 2014).
M V Pylee, India’s Constitution (New Delhi: S. Chand & Company, 2022).
Namita Rani Panda, “Gender Equality: A Hallmark of Social Development” (2014) 41:3 Indian Bar Review.
Neela Ghoshal & Kyle Knight, Rights in Transition: Making Legal Recognition for Transgender People a Global Priority (Human Rights Watch, 2016).
Pallavi Hooda, “The Transgender Persons Act- A Misguided Attempt in the Pursuit of Human Rights for All” (2020) 47:4 Indian Bar Review.
Prem Kumar Agarwal, “Rights of Third Gender in India and Recent Developments: Special Reference to NLSA Judgment” (2016) 7:1 Indian Journal of Law and Justice.
Robert Wintemute, “Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual and Transgender Human Rights in India: From Naz Foundation to Navtej Singh Johar and Beyond” (2019) 12:3–4 NUJS Law Review.
Rokhmah, Dewi, Khoiron Khoiron & Ristya Widi Endah Yani, “Outlining Gay’s Right to Health in Jember, Indonesia: Challenges and Opportunities” (2020) 7:2 Lentera Hukum 137–152.
Shiva P Srinivasan & Sruti Chandrasekaran, “Transsexualism in Hindu Mythology” (2020) 24:3 Indian Journal of Metrocinology and Metabolism.
Shobharam Sharma, “Transgender in India: Human Rights and Social Exclusion” (2013) 100 All India Reporter.
Soli J Sorabjee, “Creative Role of Indian Judiciary in Enlarging and Protecting Human Rights” (2019) 106 All India Reporter.
Sunil Kumar, “Rights of Transgender Community in Conglomerate of Human Rights Regime” (2020) 47:4 Indian Bar Review.
Suzanne M Marks, “Global Recognition of Human Rights for Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual and Transgender People” (2006) 9:1 Health and Human Rights.
Tanya Singh & Kush Kakkar, “LGBTQIA+ Civil Rights in India” (2021) 2:1 Jus Corpus Law Journal.
Uday Veer Singh, “Law and Modernisation in India” (2016) 103 All India Reporter.
