Arguments to Apply Constitutional Guarantees in the Private Sector


Constitutional guarantees are such a body of interests or basic human rights which are inevitable for each human being. These rights are principally inherent, inalienable, and universal, and therefore, irrespective of race, sex, caste, color, or religion, everyone can enjoy them. Constitutional guarantees are distinct from all other rights and privileges because of at least two unique characteristics, such as intrinsic in nature, and inalienability. These guarantees are crucial in the state-individual relations, and recognized by major laws of the civilized nations, and often enshrined in the national constitutions. For instance, the US Constitution signifies the essence of these rights through the expression of life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness. Nonetheless, very often, many citizens across the globe are deprived of these rights on numerous pretends and grounds, and mostly, on the public-private dichotomy. This study examined contemporary legal and philosophical discourses as to whether the constitutional guarantees of human rights apply in the private sectors in Malaysia, India, and the United States. This study used doctrinal legal research methodology with a qualitative approach based on library resources. The findings of this study showed that constitutional guarantees, primarily human rights, are presumed to have been neither created nor made but originated like organic growth. Accordingly, no authority can take them away. By examining various logics from theological to socio-historical points of view and the theory of international law, this study concluded that constitutional guarantees, particularly the equal protection of the law, should apply horizontally to cover both public and private sectors.

KEYWORDS: Constitutional Guarantees, Human Rights, Public-Private Sectors.


Abdul Malek Ahmad PCA, et al., “Beatrice Fernandez v Sistem Penerbangan Malaysia & Anor” (2005) 3:681 Malay Law J.

Ahmad, Salbiah, Gender Equality under Article 8: Human Rights, Islam and ‘Feminisms’ (Malaysia: The Malaysian Bar, 2005).

Amar, et al., "Child Abuse as Slavery: A Thirteenth Amendment Response to DeShaney” (1992) 105:6 Harv Law Rev.

Anantaraman, Venkatraman, Malaysian Industrial Relations: Law & Practice (Universiti Putra Malaysia Press, 1997).
Austin, David, et al., “Sexual Orientation and Gender Identity” (2010) Int Lawyer.

Aziz, ZA, Developing the Doctrine of Equality-Sameness and Differences (Malaysia: The Malaysian Bar, 2005).

Baderin, Mashood A, International Human Rights and Islamic Law (OUP Oxford, 2003).

Barak, Aharon, “Constitutional Human Rights and Private Law” (1996) 3:2 Rev Const Stud.

Barnes, Robert, "Supreme Court Blocks Massive Sex-Discrimination Suit against Wal-Mart," Wash Post, online: .

Bhatt, Jashpal Kaur, “Gender Discrimination in Employment- how far does Art 8 of the Federal Constitution Guarantee Gender Equality” (2006) 6 Malay Law J.

Cane, P, Public Law and Private Law: A Study of the Analysis and Use of a Legal Concept: Oxford Essays in Jurisprudence, 3 (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1987).

Clapham, Andrew, Human Rights in the Private Sphere (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1993).

Coker, Francis William, Readings in Political Philosophy (Macmillan, 1914).

Dalrymple, G Brent, The age of the Earth (Stanford University Press, 1994).

Dhamo, Ana, “United States of America and Constitutional Guarantees” (2015) 6:3 Mediterr J Soc Sci.

Dwivedi, Krishna Chandra, Right to Equality and the Supreme Court (Deep & Deep Publications, 1990).

Engle, Eric, “Third Party Effect of Fundamental Rights (Drittwirkung)” (2009) 5:2 Hanse Law Rev.

Epstein, Richard A, “In Defense of the Contract at Will” (1984) 51:947 Univ Chic Law Rev.

Erlina & Nika Normadilla, “Gender Analysis in Indonesia’s Legislation Regarding Political Laws” (2020) 7:3 Lentera Hukum.

Faruqi, Shad Saleem, “The Constitution and the Private Sector”, Star Online, online:

Fisch, William B, “Emergency in the Constitutional Law of the United
States” (1990) 38:Suppl_1 Am J Comp Law 389–420.
Fletcher, George P, “In God’s Image: The Religious Imperative of Equality
Under Law” (1999) 99 Columbia Law Rev.
Gabriele Ullrich, Hubertus Essenberg & William Ratterree, The Impact of
Decentralization and Privatization on Municipal Services: Report for
Discussion at the Joint Meeting on the Impact of Decentralization and
Privatization on Municipal Services, by Gabriele Ullrich, Hubertus
Essenberg & William Ratterree, Sectoral Activities Programme
(Geneva: International Labour Organization, 2001).
Ghurye, G S, Caste and Race in India (Popular Prakashan, 1969).
Ginsburg, Tom & James Melton, Innovation in Constitutional Rights (2012).
Graber, Christoph B & Geunther Teubner, “Art and Money: Constitutional
Rights in the Private Sphere?” (1998) 18:1 Oxf J Leg Stud.
Greenhouse, Steven, "A New Hurdle for Suits Brought on Behalf of Many,"
N Y Times, online: 21class.html?>.
Harlow, Carol, “‘Public’ and ‘Private’ Law: Definition without Distinction”
(1980) 43:3 Mod Law Rev.

Hart-Davis, Adam, History: From the Dawn of Civilization to the Present Day (Penguin, 2012).

Hasnas, John, “Equal Opportunity, Affirmative Action, and the Anti-Discrimination Principle: The Philosophical Basis for the Legal Prohibition of Discrimination” (2002) 71 Fordham Law Rev.

Hershkoff, Helen, “Positive Rights and State Constitutions: The Limits of Federal Rationality Review” (1999) 112:6 Harv Law Rev.

Hossain, Kamrul, “In Search of Equality: Marriage related Laws for Muslim Women in Bangladesh” (2003) 5:1 J Int Women’s Stud.

Jayus, Jayus & Muhammad Bahrul Ulum, “Presidential Power’s Limitation to Emergency Provisions in Indonesia” (2020) 8:2 J Cita Huk 343–362.

Jennings, I, The Law and the Constitution (London: University of London Press, 1963).

J Mark, Joshua, "The Ancient City," online: World Hist Encycl .

Kaspersen, L Bo, “Anthony Giddens: The Consequences of Modernity” (1991) 23:1 Politica.

Kitroeff, Natalie & Jessica Silver-Greenberg, "Pregnancy Discrimination Is Rampant Inside America's Biggest Companies," N Y Times, online: .

Kurniawan, Joeni, “When Human Rights are not Enough” (2018) 2:1 J Southeast Asian Hum Rights 236–247.

Lapidus, Lenora M, Emily J Martin & Namita Luthra, The Rights of Women: The Authoritative ACLU Guide to Women’s Rights (New York: NYU Press, 2009).

Lillich, Richard B, The Human Rights of Aliens in Contemporary International Law (Manchester University Press, 1984).

Lillibridge, Nicole, “The Promise of Equality: A Comparative Analysis of the Constitutional Guarantees of Equality in India and the United States” (2004) 13 William Mary Bill Rights J.

Liu, Goodwin, Pamela S Karlan & Christopher H Schroeder, Keeping Faith with the Constitution (Oxford University Press, 2010).

Luhmann, Niklas, The Differentiation of Society (Columbia University Press, 1982).

Mears, Bill, "Supreme Court Rules for Wal-Mart in Massive Job Discrimination Lawsuit," CNN, online: .

Mitchell, Jonathan F, “Textualism and the Fourteenth Amendment” (2017) 69:5 Stanford Law Rev.

Mohamad, Rahmat, “Ratifying International Conventions”, Star Online, online: .

Ramachandran, S & Kessides, “Privatization and Deregulation: A Push Too Far?” in Econ Growth 1990 (World Bank, 1990).

Randhawa, Sharanpal Singh, “Muslim-only Launderette in Perlis”, Star Online (29 September 2017), online: .

Raub, Amy, et al., "Protections of Equal Rights across Sexual Orientation and Gender Identity: An Analysis of 193 National Constitutions" (2017) 28:1 Yale J Law Fem.

Raz, Joseph, The Morality of Freedom (Clarendon Press, 1986).

Robbers, Gerhard, Encyclopedia of world constitutions (New York: Facts On File, 2007).

Sankaran, Kamala & Roopa Madhav, Working Paper No.17: Gender Equality and Social Dialogue in India, by Kamala Sankaran & Roopa Madhav (ILO, 2010).

Tikamdas, Ramdas, “National Security and Constitutional Rights” (2003) 32:1 J Malays Bar 18.

Thomas, D, God, Locke, and Equality: Christian Foundations of John Locke’s Political Thought (Cambridge University Press, 2001).

Tribe, Laurence H, American Constitutional Law (Foundation Press, 1978.

Willke, Helmut, Stand und Kritik der neueren Grundrechtstheorie: Schritte ze normativen Systemtheorie (Duncker und Humblot, 1975).
How to Cite
ISLAM, Md. Toriqul. Arguments to Apply Constitutional Guarantees in the Private Sector. Lentera Hukum, [S.l.], v. 8, n. 2, p. 175-210, july 2021. ISSN 2621-3710. Available at: <>. Date accessed: 23 june 2024. doi:

Most read articles by the same author(s)

Obs.: This plugin requires at least one statistics/report plugin to be enabled. If your statistics plugins provide more than one metric then please also select a main metric on the admin's site settings page and/or on the journal manager's settings pages.