Death Penalty in Indonesia

Revisiting the Debate Between the Retentionist and the Abolitionist

Abstract

Historically, Indonesia's death penalty does not originate from religious doctrine but a series of democratization processes agreed upon in the legislation. Amidst these processes, two competing opinions respond to Indonesia's death penalty: the retentionist and the abolitionist. These different approaches to address the death penalty, whether imposed or abolished, result in competing perspectives and arguments in regulatory and practical issues both in the national and international arena. This study aimed to revisit the death penalty discourse in Indonesia that opposes the human approach by assuming that the death penalty violates human rights. The data were analyzed in three steps, among other things, unitization, comparison, and conclusion. This study showed that the death penalty remains relevant to Indonesia despite the long struggle of its rejection. It concluded that Indonesia's imposition of the death penalty is regarded as worth defending, with specific and selective applications. The specific application means that the death penalty is applicable for corruptors, drug dealers, terrorists, gross human rights violators, and premeditated murders. Selective application means that a convict sentenced to death must be proven in court with a level of accuracy considered and accepted in law.


KEYWORDS: Death Penalty, Criminal Law, Right to Life, Indonesian Law.

References

Adnan Buyung Nasution, Ramadhan KH & Nina Pane Budiarto, Pergulatan Tanpa Henti: Pahit Getir Merintis Demokrasi (Jakarta: Penerbit Aksara Karunia, 2014).

Afadlal, Endang Turmudi & M Riza Sihbudi, Islam dan Radikalisme di Indonesia (Jakarta: Lembaga Ilmu Pengetahuan Indonesia-LIPI dan Yayasan Obor Press, 2015).

Ali, Achmad, 50 Tahun, Usia Prof. Dr. Achmad Ali, S.H., M.H.: Karya Pilihannya dan Komentar Berbagai Kalangan tentang Achmad Ali (Penerbit S.N., 2012).

Alkostar, Artidjo, Pengadilan HAM, Indonesia dan Peradaban (Yogyakarta: PUSHAMM-UII, 2014).

Ankar, Casten, Determinants of the Death Penalty; Comparative Study of the World (London: Routledge Press, 2014)

Anwar, Yesmil, Pembaruan Hukum Pidana: Reformasi Hukum (Jakarta: Penerbit Grasindo, 2018).

Ardani, Nur Afif, Sulfi Amalia & Rooseno Hertanto, “Relativisme Budaya Dalam Hak Asasi Manusia” (2017) 14:1 30–46.

Arief, Barda Nawawi, Kebijakan dalam Penanggulangan Kejahatan dengan Pidana Penjara (Semarang: Ananta, 1994).

Baktiari, Bahman, “Iran: Shari’a politics and the transformation of Islamic law” in Sharia Polit Islam Law Soc Mod World (2011).

Brooks, Thom, Hegel’s Philosophy of Right (Wiley-Blackwell, 2011).

Cesare Lombroso, Mary Gibson & Nicole Hahn Rafter, Criminal Man (Duke: Duke University Press, 2016).

Cesare Lombroso & Henry Pomeroy Horton, Crime, its Causes and Remedies (Little, Brown and Company Press, 1918).

Clarkson, Christoper MV, Understanding Criminal Law (Sweet and Maxwell Publisher, 2005).

Darmastuti, Ari, “Kontroversi Hukuman Mati”, Lampung Post (2015).

Darmawan, Iwan, “Perkembangan dan Pergeseran Pemidanaan” (2015) 1:2 Palar Pakuan Law Rev.

David C Brody, James R Acker & Wayne A Logan, Criminal Law (US: Johns and Bartlett Publishers, 2001).

David J Cornwell & Tony Cameron, Criminal Punishment and Restorative Justice: Past, Present, and Future Perspective (United States: Waterside Press, 2016).

Dosen, Risman et al, “Polemik Pemidanaan (Kontroversi Faham Abolisionis Dan Retensionis)” (2018) 1:2 J Syariah Huk Islam 158–165.

Duncan, Mary Carter, “Playing by Their Rules: The Death Penalty and Foreigners in Saudi Arabia” (2014) Ga J Int Comp Law.

Gibbs, Jack P, “The Death Penalty, Retribution and Penal Policy” (1978) 69:3 J Crim Law Criminol 1973-291.

Gray, Cavender, “Justice, Sanctioning, and the Justice Model” (1984) Criminology.

Gunarto, Marcus Priyo, “Sikap Memidana yang Berorientasi pada Tujuan Pemidanaan” (2009) 21:1 Mimb Huk.

Hall, Jerome, General Principal of Criminal Law (The Lawbook Exchange Ltd. Publisher, 2015).

Hamid, Usman, “Hukuman Mati Bukan Sekadar Penerapan Hukum Positif”, Kompas (2013).

Hammel, Andrew, Ending the death penalty: The European experience in global perspective (Palgrave Macmillan, 2010).

Haney, Craig, Death by Design: Capital Punishment as Social Psychological System (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2005).

Harahap, Krisna, Pemberantasan Korupsi, Jalan Tiada Ujung (Penerbit Grafitri, 2016).

Hasan, Muhammad Abu, Ahkam al-Jarimah wa al-‘Uqubah fi al-Syari’ah al-Islamiyah: Dirasah Muqaranah (California: University of California Press, 2007).

Hatta, Mohammad, Mohammad Hatta (Jakarta: Tintamas, 1986).

Hatta, Muhammad, “Perdebatan Hukuman Mati di Indonesia: Suatu Kajian Perbandingan Hukum Islam dengan Hukum Pidana Indonesia” (2012) 36:2 MIQOT J Ilmu-Ilmu Keislam.

Hegel, Georg Wilhelm Fredrich, Hegel: Elements of the Philosophy of Right (Cambridge University Press, 1991).

Hiariej, Eddy OS, Prinsip-Prinsip Hukum Pidana (Yogyakarta: Cahaya Atma Pustaka, 2016).

Hood, Roger G, "The Death Penalty: A Worldwide Perspective" 225.

Husaini, Adian, Rajam dalam Arus Budaya Syahwat: Penerapan Hukum Rajam di Indonesia dalam Tinjauan Syari’at Islam, Hukum Positif dan Politik Global (Pustaka al-Kautsar, 2011).

ICJR, “Hukuman Mati di Indonesia dari Masa Ke Masa”, (2017), online: . Institute, Spectrum, Terorisme Ditengah Arus Global Demokrasi (Penerbit Spectrum, 2016).

Kholiq, M Abdul & Ari Wibowo, “Penerapan Teori Tujuan Pemidanaan dalam Perkara Kekerasan” (2016) 23:2 186–205.

Khoemaeni, Syamsul Anwar, “84 Negara Kecuali Indonesia yang Hapus Hukuman Mati”, (2015), online: Okenews .

Kurnia, Titon Slamet, Hak atas Derajat Kesehatan Optimal Sebagai HAM di Indonesia (Bandung: Penerbit Alumni, 2017).

Lacey, Nicola, State Punishment: Political Principal and Community Values (Routledge: Routledge University Press, 1994).

Liverani, Mario, “Hammurabi of Babylon” in Anc East (Routledge, 2020) 264.

Maiwan, Mohammad, “Memahami Teori-Teori Etika: Cakrawala dan Pandangan” (2018) J Uiversitas Negeri Jkt 193–215.

Mandery, Evan J, Capital Punishment: A Balanced Examination (Jones and Bartlett Publishers, 2014).

Marbun, BN, Kamus Hukum Indonesia (Jakarta: Pustaka Sinar Harapan, 2016).

Marwati Juned Pusponegoro et al, Sejarah Nasional Indonesia: Kemunculan Penjajahan di Indonesia (Jakarta: Penerbit PT Balai Pustaka, 2008).

MD, Mahfud, Hukum dan Pilar-pilar Demokrasi (Yogyakarta: Gema Media, 1999).

MD, Mahfud, Membangun Politik Hukum, Menegakkan Konstitusi (Jakarta: LP3ES, 2006).

Mieroop, Marc Van De, King Hammurabi of Babylon: A Biography (John Wiley and Sons, 2008).

Mitchell, Barry & Julian V Roberts, “Sentencing for Murder: Exploring Public Knowledge and Public Opinion in England and Wales” (2012) 52:1 Br J Criminol 141–158.

Mujani, Saiful, Muslim Demokrat: Islam, Budaya Demokrasi, dan Partisipasi Politik di Indonesia Pasca Orde Baru (Jakarta: Gramedia Pustakka Utama, 2017).

Mumisa, Michael, “Sharia law and the death penalty Would abolition of the death penalty be unfaithful to the message of Islam?” (2015).

Muryani, Maria Anna & Noor Rosyida, “The Concept of Death Penalty in a Pancasila State (Perspective of Official Religion in Indonesia)” (2020) 2:2 Walisongo Law Rev Walrev 131.

Nasution, Adnan Buyung, Arus Pemikiran Konstitusionalisme: Hukum dan Peradilan (Jakarta: Penerbit KATA, 2017).

Nathaniel Persily, Jack Kitrim & Patrick J Egan, Public Opinion and Constitutional Controversy (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2008).

Norval Morris & David J Rothman, The Oxford History of the Prison: The Practice of Punishment in Western Society (Oxford: Oxford University
Press, 1998).

Nowak, Manfred, United Nation Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, ICCPR Commentary (Leiden: N.P. Engel Publisher, 2005).

Others, Benyamin and, Prisons or Crime Prevention (England: Little Blue Book CO, 1977).

Peter Hodgkinson & William Schabas, Capital Punishment: Strategies for Abolition (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2014).

Pialang, Yasraf Amir, Transpolitika: Dinamika Politik di dalam Era Virtualitas (Penerbit Jalasutra, 2015).

Poernomo, Bambang, Asas-asas Hukum Pidana (Yogyakarta: Ghalia Indonesia, 1995).

Prasetyo, Eko, Demokrasi Tidak Untuk Rakyat (Yogyakarta: Resist Book press, 2005).

Prayitno, Sudi, “Dilema Hukuman Mati”, (2020), online: Legalitas .

Prodjodikoro, Wiryono, Asas-Asas Hukum Pidana di Indonesia (Bandung: Eresco, 1989).

Purwanto, Wawan H, Kontroversi Seputar Hukuman Mati Amrozi CS (Jakarta: Cipta Mandiri Bangsa, 2008).

Qadir, Zuly, Islam Syari’ah vis a vis Negara: Ideologi Gerakan Politik di Indonesia (Jakarta: Pustaka Pelajar, 2017).

Raffaele Garofallo & Robert Wyness Millar, Criminology (Little Brown and Company Press, 1914).

Rasjidi, Lili, Dasar-dasar Filsafat Hukum (Bandung: Citra Aditya Bakti, 1993).

Reitzenstein-Ronning, Christian, “Performing justice: the penal code of Constantine the Great” (2015) 265–288.

Romli Atmasasmita & Agus Takariawan, Reformasi Hukum, Hak Asasi Manusia dan Penegakan Hukum (Mandar Maju, 2011).

Saepullah, Asep, “Konsep Utilitarianisme John Stuart Mill: Relevansinya terhadap Ilmu-ilmu atau Pemikiran Keislaman” (2020) 11:2 Aqlania J Filsafat Dan Teol Islam 243–261.

Sahetapy, JE, Suatu Studi Khusus Mengenai Ancaman Pidana Mati terhadap Pembunuan Berencana.

Saputra, Andi, “6 Orang Dihukum Mati Sepanjang Februari 2020, Ada yang Nangis Mewek”, (2020), online: Detiknews .

Sarat, Austin & Jürgen Martschukat, Is the death penalty dying?: European and American perspectives (Cambridge University Press, 2011).

Sastrawidjaja, Sofjan, Hukum Pidana: Asas Hukum Pidana sampai Dengan Alasan Peniadaan Pidana (Bandung: Amrico, 1995).

Schabas, William, The Abolition of the Death Penalty in International Law (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2002).

Schabas, William, Discussion on Death Penalty Contemporary Challenges, Delegation of European Commission and Department of Philosophy Faculty of Humanities University of Indonesia, by William Schabas (Jakarta, 2004).

Supardi, Kajian Kritis Pro dan Kontra Pelaksanaan Hukuman Mati Di Indonesia, Khususnya Terhadap Kejahatan Narkoba (Jakarta: Badan Narkotika Nasional Republik Indonesia, 2015).

Suparni, Niniek, Tindak Pidana Subversi: Suatu Tinjauan Yuridis (Jakarta: Sinar Grafika, 1991).

Suryadi A Radjab & Ismail Hasani, Indonesia, Hilangnya Rasa Aman: Hak Asasi Manusia dan Transisi Politik Indonesia (Jakarta: PBHI dan The Asia Foundation Group Press, 2012).

Tahirulqadri, Muhammad, Islamic Philosophy of Punishments (Minhaj Quran Publication).

Tobias, JJ, Crimes and Industrial Society in the Nineteenth Century (England: Penguin Book Press, 1973).

Usman, “Analisis Perkembangan Teori Hukum Pidana” J Ilmu Huk.

Waluyo, Bambang, Pidana dan Pemidanaan (Jakarta: Sinar Grafika, 2008).

Widodo, Rusman, “Konfigurasi Pertarungan Abolisionisme Versus Retensionisme dalam Diskursus Keberadaan Lembaga Pidana Mati di Tingkat Global dan Nasional” (2012) 8 J Komnas HAM 315–348.

Wilson, William, Criminal Law: Doctrine and Theory (Longman: Longman Publisher, 2003).

Yadegarfard, Mohammadrasool, “How are Iranian Gay Men Coping with Systematic Suppression Under Islamic Law? A Qualitative Study” (2019) Sex Cult.

Yahya, Imam, “Hukuman Mati dalam Perspektif Sejarah” (2013) 23:April Al-Ahkam J Pemikir Huk Islam 81–98.

Yazid, Abdullah, “Meninjau Ulang Hukuman Mati”, (2019), online:
.

Yorke, Jon, Against the Death Penalty: International Initiative and Implication (Ashgate: Ashgate Publishing Ltd., 2019).

Yunus, Yusran, “Ini Daftar Terpidana Mati di Indonesia Yang Sudah Dieksekusi”, (2015), online: Kabar24 .

Zaibert, Leo, Punishment and Retribution (Ashgate: Ashgate Publishing
Ltd, 2016).

Zohair Husain, Mir & Stephen E Costanza, “Code of Hammurabi” in Encycl Correct (John Wiley & Sons, Inc., 2017) 1.

Zulfa, Eva Achjani, “Pergeseran Paradigma Pemidanaan di Indonesia” (2017) 36:3 J Huk Pembang 389.
Published
2021-04-24
How to Cite
SALAM, Abdul Jalil; KARIM, Zahlul Pasha. Death Penalty in Indonesia. Lentera Hukum, [S.l.], v. 8, n. 1, p. 115-150, apr. 2021. ISSN 2621-3710. Available at: <https://jurnal.unej.ac.id/index.php/ejlh/article/view/20138>. Date accessed: 23 june 2024. doi: https://doi.org/10.19184/ejlh.v8i1.20138.
Section
Articles

Most read articles by the same author(s)

Obs.: This plugin requires at least one statistics/report plugin to be enabled. If your statistics plugins provide more than one metric then please also select a main metric on the admin's site settings page and/or on the journal manager's settings pages.